CFR Education
Tools and resources for teaching and learning about U.S. foreign policy.

Teaching Notes

The Closing of the American Border

Author: Edward Alden, Bernard L. Schwartz Senior Fellow
September 2009

Visit the Book Page

Download the Teaching Notes

Book

The Closing of the American Border

by Edward Alden

twitter @edwardalden

blog Renewing America


Looking for more resources on Border and Port Security? Click here.

Looking for more resources on 9/11 Impact? Click here.

The Closing of the American Border: Terrorism, Immigration, and Security Since 9/11 tells the story of the Bush administration's efforts to balance security and openness in the wake of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. Based on extensive interviews with U.S. government officials, as well as business executives, foreign government officials, university professionals, and individuals, this book goes behind the scenes of the internal struggles over policymaking, and examines the real world impacts of those policy decisions. The result is a compelling assessment of the price the United States has paid for making it increasingly difficult for others to travel, live, and work within its borders. This book offers value on two different levels: as a case study in the development of policy and the workings of American bureaucracy, and as an analysis of American border security policy, past, present, and future.

The book concludes that, while there can be no doubt that American border policy prior to 9/11 was at times lax to a point of being na´ve, changes immediately after the attacks largely did more harm than good. It examines the complicated interplay between the United States' need for homeland security, economic openness, and the social and diplomatic benefits of maintaining a welcoming society. Finally, it recommends a greater focus on the development of smart border security measures that work as hard to invite in good people as they do to keep out bad ones.

This book, along with the teaching notes, discussion questions, and suggestions for further projects, are ideal for courses on U.S. foreign policy and international affairs; U.S. government and the development and execution of U.S. policy; U.S. border, visa, and immigration policy; the effects of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks; and civil liberties and immigrant and refugee rights.

Teaching Notes Components

Discussion Questions

Courses on U.S. Foreign Policy and International Affairs

  1. What are some examples of places where American domestic policy and politics have a powerful effect on international relations?
  2. Are American border policies principally a foreign or domestic issue? Where are places where these interests compete?
  3. Which constituencies, foreign and domestic, have a stake in the balancing act between the homeland security and border policies discussed in this book? How should U.S. policy take into account the wide variety of interests at play?
  4. In what ways did the policy changes discussed throughout this book affect the United States' global relationships and standing?

Courses on U.S. Government and the Development and Execution of U.S. Policy

  1. In what ways did competition between and within bureaucracies affect the development of border policies after 9/11?
  2. Which actors best managed the politics, internal and external, to achieve the results they wanted from these policy changes?
  3. Overall, were the policy changes after 9/11 subjected to appropriate checks and balances? Where was a policy checked by an institutional balance? Where did it seem as though the necessary balances were lacking?
  4. What lessons do the problems in the start-up of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) teach us about the difficulties of government organizations?

Courses on U.S. Border, Visa, and Immigration Policy

  1. What are some of the ways in which U.S. immigration policy has been linked to American antiterrorism objectives? Are these linkages appropriate?
  2. How has the creation of DHS and the reorganization of the U.S. departments that deal with border policy altered the United States' approach to these issues?
  3. What are some of the ways that visa and immigration policies affect the United States' global standing? Its economy?
  4. What are some of the important issues facing border officials today? Based on the policy processes seen in this book, map out a strategy for developing and enacting a policy to confront one of these challenges.

Courses on the Effects of the September 11, 2001 Terrorist Attacks

  1. Has the U.S. government been more successful in finding the necessary balance between security and openness as time has passed since the 9/11 attacks?
  2. Did the events discussed in this book reveal any problems with the U.S. government's capabilities to react to emergency situations, or the checks in balances in place?
  3. What security vulnerabilities were revealed by, and in the wake of, the 9/11 attacks? Have these been sufficiently addressed since?
  4. Given that terrorism depends as much on the damage done by the reaction to the attacks as the attacks themselves, how would you rate the American response to the 9/11 attacks? What are three ways in which the response could have been better executed?

Courses on Civil Liberties and Immigrant and Refugee Rights

  1. What are some of the differences in protections for U.S. citizens, as compared to immigrants, within American borders? Are these differences appropriate?
  2. Has the development of the Department of Homeland Security been a net boon or net loss for American civil liberties? Why?
  3. What are the major changes in immigrant and refugee rights detailed in this book? What are some of the benefits and consequences of these changes?
  4. What are some examples of when checks and balances to protect citizen and immigrant civil rights did and did not operate properly in post-9/11 policymaking?

Further Projects

Debate

Divide students into small teams and organize a debate on some of the issues raised in the book, such as:

  • The relative importance of American interests in homeland security
  • Encouraging immigration and foreign visitation as a priority for the United Sates
  • Whether the United States, on the whole, is better off since the post-9/11 policy changes
  • Whether immigration and border policy is best handled through the Department of Homeland Security

Memorandum to the President

Assign students to write a memorandum to the president summarizing the lessons learned from the events covered in this book. Ask students to suggest three policy recommendations as a result of these lessons learned, discussing the pros and cons of each option.

Memorandum to the Department of Homeland Security

Assign students to write a memorandum to be distributed among supervisors at DHS explaining steps to be taken to create an optimum balance between security and openness. This brief should include both long-term goals and new policies, as well as ground-level instructions to those on the front lines of border and homeland security efforts, such as visa officers and border inspectors.

Op-ed

Assign students to write an op-ed on some aspect of U.S. border, immigration, or homeland security policy. Assignments should be evaluated based on the importance of the topic selected, and the clarity and brevity with which the author presents a specific point of view. Because the op-ed is short, it requires different writing skills from a conventional term paper—the point must be made in the first or second paragraph, the writing style is usually more argumentative than in term papers, and the writing style must be simple even as the ideas advanced are sophisticated. These guidelines will help in focusing the argument—which is best done before writing—because many students choose arguments that are either too sprawling or esoteric for good op-eds.

Supplementary Materials

  1. Alden, Edward, "Closed-Minded on the Border," Washington Post, November 23, 2008.
  2. Muller, Benjamin J., Governing Through Risk at the Canadian/US Border: Liberty, Security, and Technology, Border Policy Research Institute Working Paper, September 2008.
  3. Secure Borders and Open Doors: Preserving Our Welcome to the World in an Age of Terrorism, Report of the Secure Borders Open Doors Advisory Committee, U.S. Department of Homeland Security, January 2008.
  4. Kerwin, Donald and Margaret D. Stock, National Security and Immigration Policy: Reclaiming Terms, Measuring Success, and Setting Priorities, U.S. Military Academy, July 2007.
  5. O'Hanlon, Michael, "Border Protection," Testimony before Congress, June 28, 2006.
  6. Yale-Loehr, Stephen, Demetrios G. Papademtriou, and Betsy Cooper, Secure Border, Open Doors: Visa Procedures in the Post-9/11 Era, Migration Policy Institute Report, September 2005.
  7. Leiken, Robert S., Bearers of Global Jihad? Immigration and National Security After 9/11, Nixon Center Report, 2004.