Renewing AmericaRenewing America

Must Read

PrintPrint EmailEmail ShareShare CiteCite
Style:MLAAPAChicagoClose

loading...

Reuters: Chinese Capitalism Is Just Another Knockoff

March 21, 2012

Share

Ian Bremmer, president of the Eurasia Group, criticizes China's version of capitalism, saying it will never "match up to the promise of a truly free capitalist economy."

Is China's system of capitalism better than that of the United States? That depends — do pigs fly? While I have no question in my mind that the U.S. is still the paragon of success when it comes to the capitalist system, lately a strange coalition of think-tankers, investors and politicians have been advancing the idea that China is eating our lunch when it comes to deploying capitalism.

More specifically, this bunch claims that China's unique brand of centrally planned capitalism is working better than the U.S.'s overregulated, bloated, inefficient and slow-growing economy. They say that our capitalism has been so bogged down by our developed-nation cost structure that we'll never again be a competitive center of investment for the great global pools of money in search of a safe investment out of which to make a parking spot. Baloney.

China has indeed grown by leaps and bounds over the past decade. That's a huge credit to a country that has modernized and industrialized on a previously unseen scale. And because of its 1.3 billion citizens, China has quite a bit of growth (read: catching up) still to come. China's style of governance leaves the country light on regulation. However, it's also light on rule of law, transparency, freedom of speech and several other key features that make the U.S. economy go 'round. Just because the Chinese government can move a village and build a road without holding a single hearing doesn't mean the free market has taken hold. Indeed, it shows the opposite: China's economy is largely state-planned, state-owned and state-run. The government uses capitalism only as a tool to reach its ends, not as a true expression of a free market.

Full Text of Document

More on This Topic

Foreign Affairs Article

Deng Undone

Author: Derek Scissors

Driven by a near obsession with economic growth, Beijing has extended the state's reach into the economy.

Analysis Brief

Bearish in Beijing

Author: Lee Hudson Teslik

China’s economy is growing at a heady clip, but a stretched stock market, burdened by restrictions on international investment, spells...