Print
Email
ShareYaleGlobal: Post 9/11 World. US President has the Lonliest Job
This article discusses forseen and unforseen challenges facing the next US president.
Interviewee: Thomas Carothers
Interviewer: Toni Johnson
February 29, 2008
The 2008 presidential primaries are being avidly followed, both at home and abroad. With all the rules for picking a party nominee, including the much-discussed Democratic superdelegates, some U.S. voters have begun questioning the extent to which the process is democratic. Thomas Carothers, an expert on democracy promotion at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, says the U.S. system for picking presidential candidates compares well with other democracies. He says the U.S. primary system allows presidential hopefuls to define and present themselves directly to the public, which is fairly unusual for established democracies. In parliamentary systems and other presidential democracies, party insiders play a much larger role, he says.
Carothers says the Democratic Party’s superdelegates would not be considered a problem by election monitors in other countries. Carothers notes that while there are no international rules for establishing party candidates, democracy-promotion experts encourage “internal democracy within parties,” a criterion that both U.S. parties meet even with the addition of superdelegates.
Carothers says developing democracies would do well to mirror the openness to new entrants in the U.S. presidential system. He also notes the “all-in” aspect of the two parties helps bring together a society that could be more politically fragmented because of its immigrant and multicultural nature. But Carothers says developing democracies should be cautious about the dominant role of money in U.S. campaigns. Developing democracies should also steer clear of the focus on individual personalities typical in U.S. politics, because it can obscure important issues, he says.
Terms of Use: I understand that I may access this audio and/or video file solely for my personal use. Any other use of the file and its content, including display, distribution, reproduction, or alteration in any form for any purpose, whether commercial, noncommercial, educational, or promotional, is expressly prohibited without the written permission of the copyright owner, the Council on Foreign Relations. For more information, write outreach@cfr.org.
Saudi Arabia on the Edge
A leading Middle East scholar pens this "good introduction to the Saudi paradox of social change and political stability and an invaluable guide to the challenges the country faces." More
American Force
An investigation of the use of American force since the end of the Cold War. More
The Struggle for Egypt
A sweeping account of Egypt in the modern era: what Egypt is, what it stands for, and its relation to the world. More
Saudi Arabia in the New Middle East
Gause posits that, though the Arab Awakening has caused tensions in Saudi-American relations, the two countries do not face a crisis and still have significant mutual interests that should be prioritized.
Partners in Preventive Action
The authors assess the strengths and weaknesses of international institutions and provide a set of practical recommendations for how the United States can strengthen the global architecture for preventive action by partnering with those organizations.
This article discusses forseen and unforseen challenges facing the next US president.
Sen. Hillary Clinton's foreign policy team included veteran Clinton administration officials seeking to revive U.S. leadership through a...
Through the U.S. presidential nominating process, voters have offered a muddled view on foreign policy issues but they continue to generate...
Michael Levi, CFR fellow for science and technology, says the next president needs a strong domestic approach to climate change to be...