PrintPrint EmailEmail ShareShare CiteCite


In Afghanistan, Path to Lasting Success Will Also Be the Hardest

Authors: Janine Davidson, and Emerson Brooking, Research Associate, Defense Policy
April 7, 2014
Council on Foreign Relations


Afghanistan's April 5 elections were well attended, successful, and – most importantly – relatively safe. According to preliminary reports, the Taliban did not launch a single major attack from the time polls opened to the time they closed. The most striking concern was not a failure in security (there were 140 attacks this year, compared to 500 in 2009), but rather a shortage of ballots. While often indicative of vote tampering, this also revealed the zeal with which Afghans went to the polls.

Although many weeks of vote tallying, debate, and a likely runoff lie ahead, by all accounts, this weekend represented the turn of a major page in Afghanistan. However, for a growing number of U.S. policymakers and an increasingly skeptical American public, this success comes as too little, too late. As the debate over the United States' post-2014 involvement in Afghanistan intensifies, the "zero option" of total force withdrawal is set to gain more political momentum.

Those U.S. commanders making the case for a reasonable residual presence of at least 10,000 advisers through 2014 and beyond face steep resistance. The war in Afghanistan is now arguably the most unpopular conflict in American history. A December CNN poll found that support for the war has dipped below 20 percent. After 2,316 American, 1,116 Coalition, and roughly 18,000 Afghan civilian fatalities; cumulative spending of more than $600 billion dollars; an often obstinate Karzai government; and nearly thirteen years of continuous fighting, there is ample argument for the United States to simply cut its losses and leave.

View full text of article.

More on This Topic


How to Safeguard Afghan Progress

Author: Max Boot
Wall Street Journal

Max Boot argues that President Obama would seriously jeopardize the recent progress in Afghanistan if he decides to leave only 5,000 troops...