The Reset Button On U.S.-Muslim Dialogue

Author: CFR.org Staff
June 4, 2009

U.S. President Barack Obama's Cairo speech calling for a "new beginning" between the United States and the Muslim world directly took on the tensions that have plagued relations, particularly since the 9/11 attacks. The speech was not heavy on concrete policy prescriptions, notes CFR's Steven A. Cook, but instead laid the groundwork for a new dialogue between the United States and Muslims. Cook, speaking with CFR.org,  said it was significant that Obama took on all the hot-button issues between the two sides, in particular the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

"The fact he has, in the run-up to the speech and during the speech, called the Israelis out on settlements and the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people was extraordinarly important  for a Muslim audience, but equally important was the fact that he called out Muslims and Arabs for their vilification of Jews, for their denial of the Holocaust, for their denial of the historical suffering of Jews, and for the legitimate right of Israel to exist in the Middle East. [He was] essentially saying to both communities, if you truly want peace and security, you're going to have to make these dramatic steps" toward a two-state solution and reconciliation.

An initial reaction roundup from Reuters showed Arab commentators expressing a mixture of goodwill and skepticism toward the speech.  Similar initial sentiment was gathered from Israeli sources by the Los Angeles Times .

Emile Hokayem writes in The National, a United Arab Emirates paper, that Obama is starting a dialogue that is long overdue.

Iran's supreme leader made a statement ahead of Obama's speech that "beautiful" words alone could not remove the distrust the Middle East feels toward Washington (FT).

Poll numbers suggest significant rifts remain between the peoples of the United States and the Muslim and Arab worlds. New data from the U.S.-based Pew Center show Arab approval ratings of the U.S. president have improved, generally, since Obama took office, but are still low in most Arab countries. Al-Jazeera reports on different data from Pew showing that 46 percent of U.S. respondents held an unfavorable view of Muslim countries--though this number, too, has risen, up 5 percent from 2002.

The BBC has a video segment examining how Middle Eastern countries and media view Obama's visit and his speech. A series of correspondents note that Muslim populations are generally attuned to the "change of language" Obama has brought to the region's many political issues, but that most also remain somewhat skeptical of the extent to which the administration will change U.S. policy.

Background and Analysis:

CFR's Steven Cook explains Obama's main objectives on his current Mideast trip.

CFR's President Richard Haass gives his take on how Obama should address the Muslim world in a new Wall Street Journal op-ed.

A report from the U.S.-Muslim Engagement Project details a comprehensive approach to improving U.S.-Muslim relations.

More on This Topic