Council on Foreign Relations Press
The tax treatment of oil and gas investment in the United States has been a contentious policy issue for decades. Reform advocates argue that eliminating tax preferences for producers of oil and gas could increase government revenues by billions of dollars each year while defenders of the existing tax regime contend that changing it would lead to large declines in domestic oil and gas production and to significant job destruction. Against the backdrop of low oil prices and increased domestic production, Gilbert E. Metcalf models firm behavior in response to the potential loss of each of the three major tax preferences in the United States. The potential losses are measured as equivalent price impact (EPI), the percentage drop in the price of oil or gas that would reduce the profitability of drilling a well as much as tax reform would.
The author finds that removing tax preferences would increase the global price of oil by only 1 percent by 2030. Domestic oil production could drop 5 percent and global consumption could fall by less than 1 percent in that timeframe. Meanwhile, domestic natural gas prices could rise between 7 and 10 percent, and both domestic gas production and consumption could fall between 3 and 4 percent. The author concludes that the estimated effects of removing the preferences on energy prices, domestic production, and global consumption suggest that none of the three preferences directly and materially improve U.S. energy security or mitigate climate change. If eliminated, however, they could enhance U.S. influence to advocate for international climate action and generate fiscal savings.
Selected Figures From This Report
Gilbert E. Metcalf is professor of economics at Tufts University, where he serves as director of graduate studies in economics. He is also a research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research.
Subscribe to This Month in Geoeconomics
The Center for Geoeconomic Studies works to promote a better understanding of how economic and geopolitical forces interact to influence world affairs.
Follow via Facebook
CFR experts examine domestic and foreign policy questions surrounding energy, security, and climate change.
Receive Blog Posts by Email
A Great Place to Have a War
The definitive account of the secret war in Laos, which forever changed the CIA from a relatively small spying agency into an organization with vast paramilitary powers. More
A World in Disarray
CFR President Haass argues for an updated global operating system to address challenges from terrorism to climate change. More
Failure to Adjust
Alden provides an enlightening history of the last four decades of U.S. trade policies and a blueprint for how to keep the United States competitive in a globalized economy. More
View Complete List
Independent Task Force Reports
2016 Annual Report
Highlights From 2015–2016
Learn more about CFR’s mission and its work over the past year in the 2016 Annual Report. The Annual Report spotlights new initiatives, high-profile events, and authoritative scholarship from CFR experts, and includes a message from CFR President Richard N. Haass.
Read and download »
The Winter 2017 issue
of CFR's member newsletter, the Chronicle
, is a guide to CFR's most important news since November 2016, and includes announcements about new programs, partnerships, fellows, meetings, publications, and members. Read it now.
Now Available: Foreign Policy Begins at Home
New Foreign Affairs eBook: Tiananmen and After