Interviewees: Lt. Col. John Nagl, Commander, 1st Battalion, 34th Armor Regiment at Fort Riley, Kansas
Lt. Col. Paul Yingling, Commander, 1st Battalion, 21st Field Artillery Regiment at Fort Hood, Texas
Interviewer: Greg Bruno, Staff Writer
February 13, 2008
Lt. Col. John Nagl and Lt. Col. Paul Yingling are among those advocating change. Both men have served with distinction in Iraq, and both currently command an army battalion. But they’ve also gone somewhere most uniformed officers seldom tread: They’ve taken their gripes with army doctrine public. In this podcast interview with CFR.org, Nagl argues the U.S. military must shift from a traditional combat force to one focused on advisory and stability missions. Yingling says a greater burden for war fighting and reconstruction must be carried by others branches of the U.S. government.
Their observations, which have won both supporters and detractors, were first raised in their professional writings. Nagl, who recently announced his retirement from the army (WashPost), explored lessons from past counterinsurgencies in his acclaimed 2002 book, Learning to Eat Soup with a Knife: Counterinsurgency Lessons from Malaya and Vietnam. Yingling made waves in May 2007 when he directly challenged the army’s officer corps with a scathing article blaming the failings in Iraq, like Vietnam, on the shortsightedness of a generation of generals.
The story of the tragic and often tormented relationship between the United States and Pakistan, and a call to prepare for the worst, aim for the best, and avoid past mistakes. More
An authoritative and accessible look at what countries must do to build durable and prosperous democracies—and what the United States and others can do to help. More
A groundbreaking analysis of what the changes in American energy mean for the economy, national security, and the environment. More
A new wave of sectarian violence has broken out in Iraq as the United States shifts its military and strategic focus to Afghanistan. Analysts...
President Obama says ending the war in Iraq will require a new definition of victory, and experts add that the United States should expect no...
Passage of security agreements between Washington and Baghdad suggest the United States has moved toward the exit in Iraq, though the path to...