PrintPrint CiteCite
Style: MLAAPAChicago Close


A Bad, Necessary Bill

Author: Michael J. Gerson, Roger Hertog Senior Fellow
February 18, 2009
The Washington Post


The stimulus package is a terrible piece of necessary legislation.

Its flaws are gaudily obvious. The bill was written in monopartisan secrecy, weighed down by irrelevant spending, considered in a rushed, uninformed debate and passed on a virtually party-line vote. The law contains provisions that seem to weaken welfare reform and invite trade disputes. And it adds a massive burden of debt to existing massive entitlement obligations requiring massive borrowing from international sources--or, if such credit dries up, the massive printing of money to buy these bonds, leading to inflation.

But while the legislation was deeply flawed, there was little alternative to action. The usual recession remedy--the lowering of interest rates by the Federal Reserve to loosen up credit and spending--is of little use when the credit system itself is broken and rates are already near zero. The president and Congress were left with one option: attempting a fiscal jolt to counter the economic cycle. Such efforts in the past have often been mistimed, with the cavalry arriving just after the settlers have been massacred. But one has to try. In this case, necessity was the mother of excess.

Beneath that excess, however, the stimulus does have a hidden virtue. A good portion of the funding is channeled to the poor through programs such as food stamps, unemployment insurance, the child tax credit and the earned-income tax credit.



View full text of article.

More on This Topic


A Week of Hunger

Author: Michael J. Gerson
Washington Post

Michael Gerson argues that despite rising food prices, the U.S. government has the ability to practically end hunger within its borders. And...


The GOP's Pocketbook Issue

Author: Michael J. Gerson
Washington Post

In this op-ed article, Gerson says that Republicans need to show the same capacity to speak to the largest economic challenge of our moment...