Center for Preventive Action Workshop on Preventive Force and U.S. Foreign Policy
Director: Micah Zenko, Fellow for Conflict Prevention
April 14, 2011 - April 14, 2011
This workshop was made possible by the generosity of the Carnegie Corporation of New York.
Meetings
Roundtable Meeting
Legal Challenges
Speakers: John B. Bellinger III, Council on Foreign Relations
Todd Buchwald, U.S. Department of State
Chair: Ashley S. Deeks, Columbia Law School
April 14, 2011
What is the legal legitimacy of preventive force today? Do states agree on what constitutes preventive force? Can there be clear distinctions between anticipatory, preemptive, and preventive uses of force? How has the Iraq War and current operations in the AFPAK region affected debates about legal or political norms governing preventive force and the level of certainty states should have before they act? How do allies and adversaries view U.S. roles and missions for preventive force? What are the authorization and/or oversight roles for Congress?
Conference Panel Session
Evolving Missions and Imperatives for Preventive Force
Speaker: Kori Schake, Hoover Institution
Chair: Micah Zenko, Council on Foreign Relations
April 14, 2011
What are the current missions where the use of preventive force can serve U.S. interests? How might foreseeable changes in the strategic environment increase the imperatives for using force preventively in the future? What do we know about the efficacy and costs of using preventive force against different kinds of adversaries and in different contexts, for example against terrorists , WMD related targets, and potentially for humanitarian missions? Is this likely to change and would these lessons be broadly applicable to other possible applications conceivable in the future?
Roundtable Meeting
Operational Opportunities and Constraints
Speaker: Herbert S. Lin, NAS
Chair: Micah Zenko, Council on Foreign Relations
April 14, 2011
What new capabilities or organizational changes are needed to provide effective and timely preventive options for policymakers? What technological advancements, including cyberwarfare, have enlarged the scope of preventive military options? Are there prospective technological/organizational breakthroughs that will make preventive actions more feasible or likely? What are the intelligence and operational requirements of locating, targeting, and attempting to destroy WMD facilities? What are the opportunities for using force against terrorists' infrastructure or state-sponsors? What is the status/relevance of Prompt Global Strike? What are the opportunities and constraints for offensive cyber operations? How can the United States leverage allied intelligence/military capabilities?