Must Read

PrintPrint EmailEmail ShareShare CiteCite


Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review: An Inquiry into the Dynamics of Government Secrecy

Author: Steven Aftergood
June 13, 2013


"[U.S.] secrecy policy is founded on a set of principles so broadly conceived that they do not provide unequivocal guidance to government officials who are responsible for deciding whether or not to classify particular topics."

On his first full day in office, President Obama famously committed his Administration to "creating an unprecedented level of openness in Government." This commitment was itself unprecedented. Never before had an incoming President singled out openness as an essential, even paramount, quality of good government and adopted it as his virtual trademark.

In an implicit rebuff to the secrecy policies of the previous Administration, the President said such openness would have to be "created" — it did not yet exist. But he assured Americans it would come to pass. "We will work together to ensure the public trust and establish a system of transparency, public participation, and collaboration."

This presidential pledge at first seemed to herald a new dawn of open government. Freedom of information advocates anticipated sharp reductions in official secrecy and substantial reforms in the classification system by which the government determines whether to withhold national security–related information from public disclosure. Soon, however, as idealized scenarios of openness went unrealized and familiar patterns of official secrecy persisted and grew, the President's commitment came to inspire disappointment, then criticism, and finally bitter mockery.

Full Text of Document

More on This Topic

Foreign Affairs Article

Reforming the NSA

Authors: Daniel Byman and Benjamin Wittes

The long-running debate over the tradeoffs the United States should make between national security and civil liberties flared up...

Foreign Affairs Article

Privacy Pragmatism

Author: Craig Mundie

Ever since the Internet became a mass social phenomenon in the 1990s, people have worried about its effects on their privacy.

Foreign Affairs Article

Hypocrisy Hype

Authors: Martha Finnemore and Michael Cohen

In their essay "The End of Hypocrisy" (November/December 2013), Henry Farrell and Martha Finnemore argue that the biggest threat from leakers...