We Must Guard Against the Worst in a Nonpolar World

Author: Richard N. Haass, President, Council on Foreign Relations
April 24, 2008
The Daily Star

Today’s world is dominated not by one or two or even several powers, but rather is influenced by dozens of state and nonstate actors exercising various kinds of power. A 20th century dominated first by a few states, then, during the Cold War, by two states, and finally by American preeminence at the Cold War’s end, has given way to a 21st century dominated by no one. Call it nonpolar.

Three factors have brought this about. First, some states have gained power in tandem with their increased economic clout. Second, globalization has weakened the role of all states by enabling other entities to amass substantial power. And, third, American foreign policy has accelerated the relative decline of the United States vis-a-vis others. The result is a world in which power is increasingly distributed rather than concentrated.

The emergence of a nonpolar world could prove to be mostly negative, making it more difficult to generate collective responses to pressing regional and global challenges. More decision-makers make it more difficult to make decisions. Nonpolarity also increases both the number and potential severity of threats, be they rogue states, terrorist groups, or militias.

Still, if nonpolarity is inevitable, its character is not. A great deal can and should be done to shape the nonpolar world. But order will not emerge on its own. On the contrary, left to its own devices, a nonpolar world will become messier over time.

View full text of article.

More on This Topic

Op-Ed

Who Cares Where Spain Is?

Author: Richard N. Haass
Newsweek

Richard N. Haass writes that "understanding how a candidate thinks about the world gives a better sense of how he is likely to react to both...

Article

The Restoration Doctrine

Author: Richard N. Haass
American Interest

Richard N. Haass argues that the United States should adopt a doctrine of Restoration as its guiding foreign policy framework, focusing on...

Op-Ed

Re-Orienting America

Author: Richard N. Haass
Project Syndicate

Richard N. Haass argues that U.S. foreign policy had become preoccupied with the Middle East, but it is now correctly refocusing on East Asia...