Teaching Module: America the Vulnerable: How Our Government Is Failing to Protect Us from Terrorism
Author: Stephen E. Flynn
Updated: March 2007
Three years after September 11, the United States is still dangerously unprepared to prevent or respond to another attack on its soil. Faced with this threat, the United States should be operating on a wartime footing at home. But despite the many new security precautions that have been proposed, America’s most serious vulnerabilities remain ominously exposed.
Publication and Teaching Notes
by Stephen Flynn
America the Vulnerable offers valuable insight into the ongoing exposure of our nation to catastrophic terrorist attacks and the struggle to reduce its myriad vulnerabilities. The book is suitable for courses on terrorism, national security, homeland security, and emergency preparedness at the graduate and undergraduate levels.
America the Vulnerable can be used as a field guide for the study of homeland security, offering a background on most of relevant issues including port and container security, aviation security, and critical infrastructure protection. It can also be used in any course that covers public policy and public administration.
- The author asserts that, “the same forces that helped to produce the horror that befell the nation [on 9/11] continue to gather strength” (p. 1). To what forces is the author referring?
- In the time since the book was published in August of 2004, what evidence is there that these forces have continued to strengthen? What counter-evidence is there to suggest that America is becoming more secure?
- Does America’s overwhelming conventional warfare capability invite an asymmetric response as proposed in the Chinese strategy book Unrestricted Warfare (p. 8)? Have the priorities and organization of the U.S. national security establishment changed sufficiently in the 21st century to best deal with the terrorist threat?
- In Chapter 3, the author offers a litany of policy failures and vulnerabilities. What progress might a supporter of the Bush administration point to since the book’s publication to suggest that these are being addressed? Is the United States better prepared now for a terrorist attack than it was two years ago?
- “Terrorists are in the driver’s seat when selecting the time, place and method of their attack” (p. 78). Explain why this suggests that security measures must be designed to operate more like a “healthy human immune system” than a reaction triggered by a specific threat.
- In Chapter 5, the author proposes a new concept for securing ports and shipping containers. If such a system had been in place before March of 2006, would the Dubai Ports World purchase of five container terminals in the United States have been so controversial? What does this chapter suggest about the relative importance of who operates terminals vis-à-vis other security considerations?
- Evaluate the author’s proposal for establishing a “Federal Security Reserve System” (p. 245-255). Why does the author see a need for such a system?
- To what extent do the contrasting views between Democrats and Republicans about the role of the federal government on social and domestic issues and on national security explain the lack of bipartisan consensus on homeland security?
- The author suggests that “homeland security measures will have derivative benefits for other public and private goods” (p. 168). Why does he make this argument? What are the benefits he lists? What others can you think of?
- In the War on Terrorism, is the best strategy to rely primarily on offense?
- Does the absence of a terrorist attack on American soil since 9/11 suggest that current efforts are sufficient?
- Should Americans be willing to make a tradeoff between security and liberty?
- Was creating the U.S. Department of Homeland Security the right decision?
- Should homeland security be separated from national security?
Mock Homeland Security Council Meeting
At the end of the hypothetical scenario laid out in Chapter 2, “The Next Attack”, the Secretary of Homeland Security offers the President two options: 1) reopen the borders and ports so as to get the economy moving again or; 2) initiate full inspection of all people, vehicles, and cargo entering the country. Assign the various roles on the Homeland Security Council and have students debate the two options. Have them outline the risks associated with each option, require them to choose the option they would recommend the President to take, and provide an outline of a Presidential Address defending their choice.
Foreign Affairs Articles
Multimedia Symposium Archive
Books & Reports
Videos and Podcasts
What is a CFR Teaching Module
Teaching Modules—featuring teaching notes by the authors of CFR publications—are designed to assist educators in creating or supplementing a course syllabus. The modules are customized packages built around a primary CFR text, such as a book or report, and include teaching notes; additional readings; video, audio, and transcripts of CFR meetings; Foreign Affairs articles; and other online resources. Use of these modules is free of charge. They may be used in part or in their entirety.
Subscribe to the Daily News Brief
Maximalist finds lessons in the past that anticipate and clarify our chaotic present, revealing the history of U.S. foreign policy in an unexpected new light. More
By All Means Necessary
This clear and authoritative book presents a sweeping account of China's global resource quest and the unrivaled expansion of its economy. More
No Exit from Pakistan
The story of the tragic and often tormented relationship between the United States and Pakistan, and a call to prepare for the worst, aim for the best, and avoid past mistakes. More
View Complete List
Independent Task Force Reports
New Council Special Reports
Limiting Armed Drone Proliferation
The authors argue that it is essential to begin working now to expand and establish rules and norms governing armed drones, thereby creating standards of behavior that other countries will be more likely to follow.
Reorienting U.S.-Pakistan Strategy
The author examines Pakistan's complex role in U.S. foreign policy and advocates for a two-pronged approach that works to quarantine threats while integrating Pakistan into the broader U.S. agenda in Asia.
Afghanistan After the Drawdown
The authors assess the political, security, and economic challenges facing U.S. policymakers in Afghanistan and evaluate a range of policy options.
Complete list of Council Special Reports
Now Available: Foreign Policy Begins at Home
New Foreign Affairs eBook: Tiananmen and After