Must Read

PrintPrint EmailEmail ShareShare CiteCite


VoxEU: Tax Expenditures: The Big Government Behind the Curtain

Authors: Leonard Burman, and Marvin Phaup
November 17, 2011


Leonard Burman and Marvin Phaup argue in favor of curtailing tax expenditures in order to address the federal debt.

As the US tries to cut back its debt, the battle lines are already being drawn. Republicans are in favour of spending cuts; Democrats in favour of tax rises. Putting political ideology to one side, this column asks what objective economics has to say.

As the Congressional Super Committee grapples with painful options to cut the federal debt, taxes have become the sticking point. Democrats have insisted that tax increases be part of any agreement while Republicans counter that all the cuts must come on the spending side.

Absent ideological objections, there really should be no conflict. Public finance economists and academic tax lawyers have long recognised that there are a number of spending programmes run through the tax code.

  • The biggest "tax expenditures" – the tax exclusion for health insurance and the mortgage interest deduction – are just subsidy programmes run through the income tax rather than a programme agency. (See Table 1.)
  • Repealing or curtailing some of those subsidies would simultaneously increase tax revenues and cut spending.

It could, in principle, be a solution to the logjam over the debt.

Full Text of Document

More on This Topic

Analysis Brief

Shrugging Off Sanctions

The UN Security Council has barred member states from supplying North Korea with missile parts in response to recent tests. The country with...


China's Soft Power

China is expanding the use of its diplomatic and cultural influence—known as 'soft power'—around the world, even as the influence of the...

Analysis Brief

China's Military 'Threat'

The annual Pentagon report on China's military power cites increased defense spending as a threat to the stability of Asia, and contends...