Cybersecurity Debate: Three Things to Know

April 27, 2015

Cybersecurity Debate: Three Things to Know
Explainer Video
from Video

The debate over cybersecurity is heating up again in Washington. Congress is considering multiple pieces of legislation intended to enhance the ability of the private sector and government to share information about digital threats. Meanwhile, the White House has put forth its own proposal, which diverges from those measures on major issues. Robert Knake, CFR’s senior fellow for cyber policy, offers three things to know about the debate on cybersecurity information sharing.

More From Our Experts

Expanded Monitoring: Congress and the White House generally agree on the need for the private sector and government to share intelligence about cyber threats. Where they diverge is on the extent to which private service providers, such as AT&T and Verizon, can monitor Internet traffic, explains Knake.

More on:

United States

Cybersecurity

Improved Sharing: Most companies already monitor their networks for threats and share cybersecurity information with other firms and government, says Knake. President Barack Obama’s proposal would simply clarify that authority, while bills supported by the Congressional intelligence committees would allow ISPs to monitor all traffic crossing their networks.

Choosing a Portal: President Obama wants cybersecurity information shared between the government and the private sector to pass through the Department of Homeland Security, while congressional intelligence committees want the National Security Agency to be the hub. These divisions do not fall along partisan lines, says Knake.

More on:

United States

Cybersecurity

Up
Close

Explore More on CFR

Russia

A quarter-century after the end of the Cold War, we unexpectedly find ourselves in a second one. The United States and its partners have a large stake in greater Russian restraint while Vladimir Putin remains in power—and in a Russia characterized by other than Putinism after he is gone.

China

Food and Water Security

A historic dry spell has severely affected Cape Town's water supply, and global climate patterns suggest that other cities may face the same fate.