Targeted Killings of Americans: Three Things to Know

February 6, 2013

Targeted Killings of Americans: Three Things to Know
Explainer Video
from Video

A leaked government document laying out the legal framework for "a lethal operation directed against a U.S. citizen who is a senior operational leader of al-Qa’ida or an associated force," has recharged the controversy over targeted killings of Americans. Matthew C. Waxman, adjunct senior fellow for law and foreign policy at CFR, highlights three legal considerations.

More From Our Experts
  • Is the U.S. at war? If the United States is engaged in a war with al-Qaeda, "the president can, as is customary in war, detain and kill enemy fighters," Waxman explains. The leaked Department of Justice memo stipulates that this is in fact the case, though many people disagree, he says.

More on:

Terrorism and Counterterrorism

  • Checks and balances: The leaked memo instructs that while U.S. citizens are entitled to due process, that doesn’t necessarily mean judicial process, Waxman notes. "However, if there isn’t judicial review, it’s especially important that we have other types of checks, including congressional oversight and strong internal executive branch review procedures," he says.

More on:

Terrorism and Counterterrorism

  • Legal doesn’t mean wise: "The leaked document provides a legal justification for targeting some enemy American citizens, but that something is legal doesn’t make it wise," says Waxman. Targeted killings must be used judiciously so as not to undermine public support for counterterrorism efforts and other foreign policy priorities, he cautions.

More on:

Terrorism and Counterterrorism

More on:

Terrorism and Counterterrorism

Up
Close

Top Stories on CFR

Hungary

The European Parliament’s vote to reprimand Hungary over its growing authoritarianism has tested the EU’s readiness to stand up to illiberalism within the bloc.

United Nations General Assembly

Next week Donald J. Trump returns to the United Nations for the annual opening of the UN General Assembly. While Trump exceeded expectations during his first UN appearance last year, he will face more pushback this time around. The president will encounter a more skeptical global audience, woke to the reality that his administration's diplomacy is all take and no give.

South Korea

South Korea's President Moon Jae-in has had more success than many expected in Pyongyang for his third summit with North Korea’s Chairman Kim Jong-un.