’This Is No Longer a War of Necessity’

Richard Haass considers new approaches to the war in Afghanistan and emphasizes the importance of Pakistan is curtailing terrorism.

October 2, 2009

Interview
To help readers better understand the nuances of foreign policy, CFR staff writers and Consulting Editor Bernard Gwertzman conduct in-depth interviews with a wide range of international experts, as well as newsmakers.

SPIEGEL: A memo written by the US commander in Afghanistan, Stanley McChrystal, was recently leaked in which he asks the American people for more patience and US President Barack Obama for more troops. Isn’t it rather unusual for US generals to put so much pressure on the president?

More From Our Experts

Richard Haass: It is fine for generals and civilians to ask for more resources. One of their responsibilities is to speak truth to power if they think they need more resources to accomplish the mission. To do that in public is not appropriate, though. The president deserves to have these issues debated in private. Whoever leaked General McChrystal’s memorandum, acted unfairly and unprofessionally.

More on:

Pakistan

Afghanistan

Wars and Conflict

SPIEGEL: But should Obama follow this advice?

Haass: It would be premature to follow it at the moment. First, we need to be more confident that doing more militarily in Afghanistan will produce more results. It is not clear that will be the case. Secondly, we need to challenge the assumption that what happens in Afghanistan is critical for the global effort against terrorism.

SPIEGEL: Isn’t that effort doomed if Afghanistan remains a safe haven for terrorists? That is why the West invaded the country, after all.

More From Our Experts

Haass: That is not clear either. Even if terrorists were to be denied Afghanistan, they could operate out of other countries.

 

More on:

Pakistan

Afghanistan

Wars and Conflict

View full text of article.


 

More on:

Pakistan

Afghanistan

Wars and Conflict

Up
Close

Top Stories on CFR

U.S. Foreign Policy

Even calculating for the rising threat from China, leaving the INF puts the United States in a worse strategic position than if it were to stay in.

NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization)

The military exercises in and around Norway are a significant test of NATO’s collective defenses at a time of rising geopolitical tensions.

North Korea

The United States and South Korea are reluctant to give North Korea a test that it might fail.