Mock Presidential Speeches on Defense Policy Revised for Campaign 2000 Debates

January 7, 2003

News Releases

September 18, 2000, New York City Although the Clinton administration and Congress have added about $125 billion to the five-year defense program, the Joint Chiefs of Staff and both the Democratic and Republican candidates have argued that more funds are needed. However, the debate has focused too much on the money and not enough on defense policy strategy. Thus, the Council on Foreign Relations has revised and reissued a report, Future Visions for U.S. Defense Policy, which presents and discusses three policy options, in addition to the current one, for U.S. defense.

-- The present level of funding, which the Council CPI labels "a prudent defense," allows the U.S. military to wage two major regional conflicts nearly simultaneously and to do some peacekeeping for about $300 billion per year.

More on:

U.S. Department of Defense

Budget, Debt, and Deficits

-- The "enhanced defense" option, which would increase defense spending to $330 billion/year and assure the United States that it can execute the two-war strategy by improving U.S. military capabilities across the board and relying on allies for peacekeeping missions.

-- A "cooperative defense," which emphasizes building ad hoc international coalitions and focusing U.S. military forces on the real threats to U.S. interests "civil and ethnic violence" allowing a 15-20 percent budget cut.

-- An "innovative defense," which keeps spending at the current level but switches defense dollars to future technologies rather than maintaining the existing force structure and buying additional current-generation weapon systems.

The case for a national missile defense is made in the enhanced defense option, the case against it in cooperative defense. The publication will be the basis of a Campaign 2000 debate in Washington, D.C., at Georgetown University on September 25, 2000.

The Council on Foreign Relations, founded in 1921 and based in New York, is a national nonpartisan membership organization and think tank dedicated to fostering America’s understanding of other nations through study and debate.

More on:

U.S. Department of Defense

Budget, Debt, and Deficits

September 2000 / paper 0-87609-211-3 / 84 pp. / $10.00

Available through Brookings phone: 800-275-1447, fax: 202-797-6004, website:

For further information on this or other Council publications, contact 212-434-9516 or visit


Top Stories on CFR

NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization)

The U.S. military is considering some major shifts to its posture in Europe, including a large withdrawal from bases in Germany, that are raising security concerns on the continent.

Middle East and North Africa

The Trump administration’s case for invoking “snapback” sanctions against Iran for violating the nuclear deal rests on shallow arguments that have left Washington alone in efforts to pressure Tehran.

Food and Water Security

Global food insecurity has surged amid the coronavirus pandemic, threatening to worsen humanitarian crises and spur further mass migration.