Skip to content

Why A Palestinian State Does Not Exist and Will Not Be Created

In an essay in Mosaic, I ask why is there no Palestinian state today and explain why one will not be created.

By experts and staff

Published

Experts

Why is there no Palestinian state today, when the idea of partition is nearly a century old and the Jewish state came into existence in 1948? Will there ever be a Palestinian state, and if not what are the alternative ways of ending the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? 

I address these questions in Mosaic‘s monthly essay for September, published September 2nd. It begins this way:

Late this month, and exquisitely timed to coincide with Rosh Hashanah, the United Nations General Assembly will meet and, addressing it, the president of France will recognize “Palestine” as a state. France will be the 148th country (by most counts) to recognize a state that does not exist and never will—a “state” with no borders, no government, no economy, and no control over its claimed territory. 

The problem, I argue, is that Palestinians have never really wanted a state--and according to polls, still today have little enthusiasm for that enterprise of state-building. Their goal has been to destroy the Jewish state, and violent “resistance” continues to have high levels of support. What, then, are the alternatives to a Palestinian state that would be an immense threat to the security of Jordan and of Israel?

I invite you to read the essay, found here at the Mosaic web site.