from Latin America's Moment and Latin America Studies Program

Mexico's Election Could Leave Its Economy in Limbo — No Matter Who Wins

A union worker holds a placard as she protests outside Pemex headquarters to demand better contracts for technicians and other professionals, in Mexico City, Mexico November 7, 2017. The placard reads: "The oil is from the nation." Carlos Jasso/Reuters

April 5, 2018

A union worker holds a placard as she protests outside Pemex headquarters to demand better contracts for technicians and other professionals, in Mexico City, Mexico November 7, 2017. The placard reads: "The oil is from the nation." Carlos Jasso/Reuters
Blog Post
Blog posts represent the views of CFR fellows and staff and not those of CFR, which takes no institutional positions.

More on:

Mexico

Elections and Voting

Development

When Felipe Calderon handed the presidential sash to Enrique Peña Nieto on December 1, 2012, Mexico’s economy was just pulling out of a four-year slump. The oil sector, which covered roughly a third of the federal budget, was in decline, production down nearly 1 million barrels a day and falling fast. Monopolies and oligopolies made everyday transactions cost up to 40 percent more than if markets were more open. Mexico’s infrastructure lagged its emerging market peers; its students languished at the bottom of developed-country rankings. And more than half of its workers toiled off the books, with few benefits or legal protections.

As Peña Nieto gets ready to hand the sash to another, growth has returned—averaging a respectable if underwhelming 2.4 percent a year. Foreign direct investment is also back, with tens of billions of dollars pouring into autos, telecommunications, and energy. But for Mexico to really change, the ambitious reform project of the last five years needs to deepen. And the government’s other failures have undermined the very model that can brighten Mexico’s economic future, making any such deepening much less likely.

Peña Nieto took on Mexico’s long-standing structural barriers to growth through the Pacto por Mexico forged by its three biggest political parties, passing nearly a dozen reforms in his first 18 months to enhance competition, extend credit, revive the energy sector, expand the tax base, and better train young Mexicans.

This ambitious project led to real wins. Mobile calls now cost less than half what they used to, and mobile broadband access has become more a norm than a luxury, subscriptions up eightfold as regulators weakened telecom mogul Carlos Slim’s grip on the market. New pipelines and processing plants have eased the gas shortages formerly facing Mexico’s industrial heartland. And several million workers have emerged from the labor shadows, their firms pushed by financial incentives, temporarily lower payroll taxes and stronger enforcement to register with the government. Millions of Mexicans have opened their first bank accounts or received their first credit cards; banks now offer more mortgages, credit lines, and lending than in the past.

Yet these gains represent only a small part of what the reforms can do for Mexico. The real payoffs for consumers, companies, and the economy will only happen down the road. It will take years for the $100 billion of foreign investment in the energy sector, for instance, to stanch the long slide in production with new finds and fields, and for the transformation of the electricity grid to increase production, lower prices, and boost clean energy.

Challenges to dominant economic players and powers are just beginning: The new and fiercely independent antitrust agency COFECE has launched dozens of investigations into shipping, sugar, pharmaceuticals, airport taxis and pension managers, but the lower prices, competition, and innovation from this opening are yet to come.

Changes in the classroom have barely started. A new curriculum that moves from rote memorization to critical thinking and social and emotional learning will be rolled out only this August, with the benefits accruing to the next generation of Mexican learners.

Unfortunately, however, the country’s patience has worn thin. The government over-promised quick gains—GDP growth of 6 percent and drastic declines in poverty—leaving many Mexicans disillusioned. Mexico’s geographic economic chasms continue to deepen, the fast-paced productivity and Asian rates of economic growth in the NAFTA-linked north leaving behind the stagnating southern states. There, tens of millions of Mexicans—some 40 percent of the population—still face entrenched poverty, as good jobs remain few, and crime and migration combine to tear apart communities.

Fiscal mismanagement and greed have further eroded public trust. Overspending every year by tens of billions of dollars, the Peña Nieto administration will leave Mexico vastly more indebted than when it started, with debt rising from a third to nearly 50 percent of GDP. And his government spent poorly: Public investment has plummeted to its lowest relative levels since the 1940s, as almost all of this new largesse has gone to salaries and benefits or disappeared into private hands.

This administration’s profligacy and over-the-top corruption have cast a long shadow over the general economic consensus of the last 30 years. True, the second and third top candidates in the polls—respectively, Ricardo Anaya of the Frente alliance and Jose Antonio Meade of Peña’s PRI—promise to continue market-friendly policies, even in the face of a debt-constrained budget and battered credibility. Yet that could not be said of the populist who leads the polls, Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador. Champions of civil society, transparency, and strong independent public institutions can derive little comfort from some of his recent pronouncements. On the stump, he offers a return to a time of business subsidies, state ownership, and agricultural self-sufficiency. He repeatedly questions energy and infrastructure contracts—including those undergirding Mexico City’s new $13 billion airport—and promises to roll back the educational shifts underway.

If that happens, the as-yet-unrealized promise of faster and more inclusive growth, and of a more competitive and prosperous Mexico, could recede yet further into the future.  

View article originally published on Bloomberg View. 

View article in Spanish, published by El Financiero.

More on:

Mexico

Elections and Voting

Development

Up
Creative Commons
Creative Commons: Some rights reserved.
Close
This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) License.
View License Detail
Close