Religion and Foreign Policy Webinar: Religion, Policy, and the 2026 Midterm Elections
Event date
Speakers
- Senior Associate Director of Research, Pew Research Center
- Senior Advisor, Interfaith Alliance, Washington
- Rabbi, Northern Virginia Hebrew Congregation
- President, National Latino Evangelical Coalition
Presider
- Projects Editor, National Reporter, Religion News Service
Loading...
0:00 / 0:00
From RFP Calls.
FASKIANOS: Welcome to the Council on Foreign Relations Religion and Foreign Policy webinar series. I’m Irina Faskianos, vice president of the National Program and Outreach here at CFR.
As a reminder, today’s webinar is on the record, and the video and transcript will be made available on CFR’s website, CFR.org. As always, CFR takes no institutional positions on matters of policy.
We are grateful to have Michael Holzman, Gabriel Salguero, Maggie Siddiqi, and Gregory Smith with us to discuss the role of faith communities in the leadup to the 2026 midterm elections.
The moderator of today’s discussion is Adelle Banks. Ms. Banks is the projects editor and a national reporter for Religion News Service covering religion and race, the faith of African Americans, and partnerships between government and religious groups. She’s an award-winning journalist who joined Religious News Service in 1995 after reporting at the Orlando Sentinel, the Providence Journal, and newspapers in Syracuse and Binghamton. She is the coauthor of Becoming a Future-Ready Church: 8 Shifts to Encourage and Empower the Next Generation of Leaders, and she was honored in 2024 with the Religion News Association’s William A. Reed Lifetime Achievement Award. She will foster the discussion amongst our panelists. I will introduce them and then turn it over to Adelle.
So joining us is Michael Holzman. He is the spiritual leader of the Northern Virginia Hebrew Congregation and the founder of the Rebuilding Democracy Project, which seeks to bring specific meaningful aspects of Judaism to bear on the polarizing conversations of American public life. He has a strong commitment to lifelong Jewish education, youth programming, and social action. He has also partnered with local and national organizations to investigate the intersection of faith and democracy since 2016. And previously, he served at Congregation Rodeph Shalom in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and B’nei Israel Congregation in San Jose, Costa Rica.
Gabriel Salguero is pastor of The Gathering, a Latino-led multi-ethnic nondenominational fellowship in Orlando, Florida, and the president and founder of the National Latino Evangelical Coalition. Previously, he was the director of the Hispanic Leadership Program and the Institute for Faith and Public Life at Princeton Theological Seminar. He has written extensively on Latino evangelicalism, immigration, racism, and multicultural congregations, and he’s served on the White House Faith-Based Advisory Council in the Department of Homeland Security’s Faith-Based Security Advisory Council, among others.
Maggie Siddiqi is senior advisor at Interfaith Alliance. She is an expert in faith-based advocacy for social change, coalition building across lines of difference, and public policy on religious freedom. Previously, she serves as director of the Center for Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships at the office of the U.S. Secretary of Education under the Biden administration, and she has served as senior director of the religion and faith team at the Center for American Progress and spent nearly a decade before that in various national organizations serving American-Muslim communities.
And finally, Gregory Smith. He is senior associate director of research at Pew Research Center where he studies religion’s role in American public life, including religious change in the U.S., the intersection of religion and politics, American Catholicism, and many other topics. He’s led major public opinion studies including the center’s three religious landscape studies and authored numerous survey reports examining Christianity’s role in America’s identity and religion’s role in American society. His expertise is frequently cited in prominent media outlets such as NPR, CNN, and the New York Times.
Obviously, we have the right panel assembled for this conversation with Adelle. I’m going to turn it over to Adelle now for the discussion amongst them, and then we’ll go to all of you for your questions. Either you can raise your hand or—virtually, or you can write your question in the box. And we’d rather hear from you, so please raise your hand.
With that, Adelle, over to you.
BANKS: Thanks very much, Irina, for the introductions and for this opportunity to moderate this panel on this very timely topic about religion policy and the midterm elections.
At RNS—Religion News Service—my colleagues and I have been covering various aspects of the midterms from get-out-the-vote efforts among black churches and among conservative white Evangelical Christians, and we’ve had reporters on the ground in Michigan and others covering research about the mood of religious people and others at this time.
So hopefully, this panel will continue to shed light on the ways religion is figuring into the midterms with election day coming up on Tuesday.
So let’s start with Greg. What main points are you and others at Pew Research finding about how religion and the midterms in general are going compared to previous elections? And if you have it, how are members of particular religious persuasions thinking about this election?
SMITH: Yeah, of course. Thank you.
It’s really kind of an interesting picture because in some ways, the familiar contours of the connection between religion and politics that we’ve seen in recent years, really, recent decades, are still very much in evidence heading into this year’s midterms. But there’s also some important changes afoot.
So what do I mean? Well, some of the underlying and longstanding partisan predispositions of different religious groups are very much still in evidence. So, for example, in a survey we conducted earlier in October, we found that some of the religious groups that tend to support Republicans in elections tell us they’re going to do the same thing this year in the midterms.
The big majority of white Evangelical registered voters, for example, told us they would vote for the Republican candidate in their district if the election were held today, and among white Catholics there’s also more support for Republicans than there is for Democratic candidates, and that’s a continuation of what we’ve seen in recent years.
At the other end of the spectrum, on the other hand, you have big majorities of black Protestant voters who tell us they intend—they would vote for the Democratic candidate if the election were today. Most Hispanic Catholics say the same, in contrast with the white Catholic voters that we interviewed. Most Hispanic Catholics intend to vote for the Democratic candidate.
And, of course, we can’t forget about the religiously unaffiliated, or the nones. This is a big and growing group in American life, people who say they have no religion. That is a strongly Democratic constituency as well.
So all that is familiar. It’s similar to what we’ve seen in recent past.
What’s different? Well, the election is taking place in the context of really substantially declining approval of the way President Trump is handling his job as president. His approval rating is down since the beginning of his second term across the board in every religious group that we can look at, including among his strongest supporters.
For example, among white Evangelical registered voters, the share of them who say they approve of the way the president is handling his job today is twenty points lower than at the beginning of his second term.
So there’s been a real erosion in approval of Trump’s job performance even among his traditional supporters. So that’s kind of some of the religious context that we’re keeping an eye on headed into the elections.
BANKS: Thank you very much. Appreciate that context.
I’m wondering if we can delve into that a little more with our panelists.
For instance, Gabriel, given your leadership of the National Latino Evangelical Coalition, can you talk about what you’re hearing or aware of related to voting preferences and concerns of Latino Evangelicals and whether that has changed, at least since the last general election?
SALGUERO: Yeah. First, thank you, Adelle, for hosting us, and thanks, CFR, for hosting us.
I think that there’s been quite a shift, at least amongst Hispanic Evangelicals. So oftentimes, I always tell people when you hear the word Evangelical in the news, it’s mostly white Evangelicals.
Latino Evangelicals still, in some regards, remain invisible. But there’s about 10 million of us or so, according to the last census, and there’s been a shift, and I think that’s for several reasons.
President Trump won the majority of Hispanic Evangelical votes in the last national election. Before him, President Biden won a slim majority. President Obama won a slim majority. And so we are Latino Evangelicals, that is, the quintessential swing voters, I think.
And now I think there’s a couple factors that has decreased the popularity of the present administration. One is, obviously, the indiscriminate immigration enforcement actions. That’s a high priority amongst Latino Evangelicals because it’s impacting our communities, our children.
Some of our congregations are closing and there’s a decrease in attendance 30 percent, 40 percent, and where there’s a(n) immigration surge like Minneapolis or Chicago or other places, that number is even higher.
So that’s first and foremost amongst the minds of Latino Evangelical voters. Above that, actually, is the economy, the capacity to pay your bills and the capacity to pay for gas and the capacity to pay your children’s education.
And so those two forces, I think, are the majority forces that are impacting the swing amongst Latino Evangelicals. We are still much more conservative than our white Catholic—Latino Catholic counterparts. We’re much more conservative than they are. But I think that you will see in this election that shift of the Latino Evangelical vote.
I think the last thing that is most important is not just that, but some of the issues impacting global health, and the cuts to global health has impacted how Latino Evangelicals and other Evangelical communities have seen their voting priorities.
So all those three issues are impacting a swing and I think that’s a decrease in Latino Evangelicals voting Republican, even though we’ll vote Republican at greater numbers than Latino Catholics.
BANKS: Thank you very much.
So, Maggie, there have been these concerns about what and who might be at the polls as voters arrive there, including whether there’s a question about whether ICE officers or National Guard personnel might be there.
So I’m wondering if you can speak about the kinds of preparations Interfaith Alliance has made to train some people for certain roles aimed at helping that potential situation or just generally helping voters.
SIDDIQI: Yeah. So this is of utmost importance to us at Interfaith Alliance as we speak. Several of my colleagues are on our “The Vote is Sacred” bus tour, which is our thirty-one-day, thirty-three-city, sixteen-state, 9,000-mile journey across the country to promote local efforts to both sow confidence in our elections, to celebrate the rights and dignity of every citizen in America, to make their voice heard through their vote, and to ensure we have safe and free elections.
We plotted the tour guided by the Voting Rights Lab’s election risk heat map, places where we anticipate there could be attempts to intimidate voters or otherwise interfere with there being a fair electoral process, and this tour is actually the culmination of our year-long focus on election protection and training up faith communities in nonviolence—nonviolent nonpartisan tactics to protect our elections.
We’ve reached more than a hundred thousand Americans this year with our new faith-based anti-authoritarianism curriculum. We’ve had a number of faith leaders go through our multi-day training of trainers programs. We’ve offered $200,000 in nonpartisan election-related grants to many of our forty affiliates and other local groups, believing that local leaders know how best to serve their communities.
And we’ve held trainings with many different organizations, such as Protect Democracy, knowing that there could be these attempts, right, to deceive the American public around what the electoral process looks like, to disrupt the voting process, or even to deny the results.
And so that’s why, you know, on election day itself we’re going to be in touch with our local partners, ensuring that we’re supporting them in case there are any threats on the day of, and our tour is actually going through election day.
We’re finishing in Denver on Thursday, November 5, because we are going to uplift our voices to ensure that every vote is counted, that the results are certified, that the new Congress is seated.
These are things we’ve, perhaps, taken for granted in years past. We don’t want to take for granted this time around, and ensuring that, you know, we live by that motto that every vote is sacred, as the late Congressman John Lewis once said.
BANKS: Thank you. We may circle back to some of that in a few minutes.
But first, Michael, you are both a congregational rabbi and the leader of interfaith efforts of a variety of kinds. What are you focusing on as people in your circles are looking towards the election and are concerned about division as the election day approaches?
HOLZMAN: Yeah, thank you so much, and like Gabriel said, I’m really honored to be here and grateful to CFR for hosting me and having me here. It’s great to be on this panel with such great people.
What I’m hearing is a combination of things—a background noise, a background static, of despair, and a background feeling like the system is generally not working for anybody, and so there’s a great deal of energy for change and also a great deal of skepticism and apprehension about the possibility of change and moving ahead.
And so, you know, I’m trying to work with local faith leaders, congregational leaders, to help inspire their congregations to turn to their inner religious resources for hope. All of our traditions tell us not to be afraid because we’re part of a transcendent human story that certainly is much longer than any election cycle.
And so by tapping into that transcendence and that moral message, and the religious practices like studying scripture together and praying and sitting in silence, these kinds of things can help us remember as human beings that we’re here for something greater.
So turning that to the particulars of this election, we’ve been doing a lot of work with having multi-faith groups study some famous American words from President Lyndon Johnson, from Elizabeth Cady Stanton in the Declaration of Sentiments, and things like that, studying these documents together, talking about what they said about voting as a sacred American religious practice, really, and how it was a reflection of what God wanted for all of us to express our humanity with our voices in the political arena.
So by tapping into that, we’ve discovered a great deal of trust and a desire to help each other through this period and a commitment to stand with local officials when it comes time to count the vote and when the pressure begins to decertify or not certify.
You know, research in the past has shown that faith leaders standing up with local officials really makes a difference to counter that pressure not to certify. So we’re ready for that, too.
BANKS: Thank you.
So that word apprehension has come up, and concerns in general. There have been any number of scenarios raised about possibilities beyond election day where the next processes of vote counting and vote certification, people—maybe even people being sworn in, could be disrupted. There’s just all these questions.
So, Greg, I’m wondering whether there’s anything you can share about the confidence people have had in various kinds of voting, whether it’s early, mail-in, absentee, or expectations about how smoothly it’ll go or not.
SMITH: Yes. My colleagues here at Pew Research Center in our political polling unit did some polling earlier this month about confidence in elections with an eye toward this year in particular, and the data are really interesting.
So, on the one hand, most people express kind of an optimistic view. Most people tell us that they expect the election will be run well. Most people tell us they think that ballots will be handled securely. Most people tell us they think the winner of the election will be clear shortly after the election’s over, within a few days. So there is a lot of optimism about how things will go this year.
On the other hand, there’s also signs of specific concerns and big partisan divisions in the nature of those concerns.
So what do I mean? Well, for example, Republicans, people who say they intend to vote for Republican candidates, they are much more confident than Democratic supporters that every eligible person who wants to vote will be able to cast a vote. Republicans are pretty confident about that, Democrats less so.
On the flip side, Democratic supporters are very confident that people who are not eligible to vote, people who are not citizens, will in fact not be able to vote. Republicans express much lower confidence that that is the case.
So you see kind of conflicting concerns between the two parties, and those concerns filter through religion as well. So what it means is that the religious groups that tend to vote for Democrats are more confident than some other groups to think people who aren’t really eligible to vote won’t be able to do so.
Religious groups that tend to vote for Republicans like white Evangelicals they tell us they’re more confident than some other religious groups that everybody who wants to vote will in fact be able to cast a ballot. So that’s kind of the picture that we’re seeing.
There’s another interesting question in the survey about intimidation at polling places, the level of—how confident are you that people who might try to intimidate voters or suppress voting at polling places will be prevented from doing so?
Most people say they’re confident about that, but Republicans are a little more confident about that than Democratic supporters are.
Now, one thing that question does not specify is the origin or the source of any such potential intimidation. Like, could that be coming from other voters or other people in the community or activists or government officials?
It doesn’t get more specific than that, but that’s kind of the overall picture that we’re seeing.
BANKS: Thank you.
So, in light of that, Gabriel, I’m wondering whether you can speak about—a little bit more about the concerns about people in Latino Evangelical communities and whether they are concerned about even leaving their homes to go into the voting booth, and whether there are certain demographic groups within this country that are just so fearful that they may not vote.
SALGUERO: There’s some concern—and I don’t want to limit it to Latino Evangelicals uniquely, but this is the group I know the most—so much so that our coalition, the National Latino Evangelical Coalition, launched a national campaign called the Peacemakers Poll Chaplains campaign, and the purpose of that is to train clergy and lay leaders to be a calming, peaceful, deescalating presence at the polls when people go to vote.
I think that there is much chatter and much conversation of will ICE be present at the voting booths, will law enforcement be present. And even if that were not the case, the insinuation, the possible reality, or the impression that that may happen already has some people nervous.
And so we have decided to train poll chaplains across the country to say, hey, be there. It’s nonpartisan. Now, look, it’s nonpartisan. We don’t endorse candidates. But just to say, hey, your voice matters. Your vote matters.
You have to remember that many Latinos come from countries where voting came at a high price and some of their votes were not counted, and so that history is deeply impressed upon them, and so I think they view that through that.
So I think that there is some concern, but at the same time, faith leaders of the Latino Evangelical and other branches of faith are responding to say, hey, we’re here. We want to make sure that democracy is a high value for us. Many of us have lost our lives in our countries defending democracy, not to mention the civil rights movements and African-American leaders and others, and so we want to be seen in that prophetic stream.
At the same time, some people are just not coming out even though they may be citizens because they fear racial profiling. They feel they’re going to be pulled over and they don’t want to deal with the hassle.
As I mentioned earlier, it’s impacted our worship attendance. It’s impacted our Sunday school attendance, and that is, I think, filtering into the vote this week. Many people are saying, hey, I’m going to try to vote early; in case there’s a hassle I can resolve it before the day of election. So I see some of that response.
But there is some concern and some anxiety, and as the rabbi say and Sister Maggie said, our job as people of faith is to deescalate and tell people not to be afraid. There are independent, nonpartisan observers that want to make sure your voice and your vote count.
BANKS: Thank you.
Michael, and then maybe Maggie, could you talk a little bit more about what faith leaders and communities are doing to address this overall concern about things not going as smoothly as people might hope they would even after the voting, and what you’re doing to try to address that specifically?
HOLZMAN: Sure.
I think in my line of work, you know, it can be kind of lonely to lead a congregation. There are congregations everywhere in America. There’s actually about two and a half times as many congregations as there are K-12 schools so it’s a lot of congregations, and the professionals who work in those buildings have deep, deep connections to the local communities.
You know, when you own a building that’s got a mortgage and has been someplace for a long time, it means you’re committed. And so we also often don’t even know the pastor down the street. Sometimes it’s a theological difference and sometimes it’s just we’re all too busy, stretched too thin.
So what we’re discovering is that when we get clergy together, they rediscover a sense of civic infrastructure, a sense of civic duty and service, and simply reaching out to the local county election official and saying we’re here for you can do wonders. We’ve been doing that in my local area, and many of our clusters around the country have been talking about the election with each other, and that has given clergy a great deal of energy and sustenance as we face a hard time.
That sustenance, that sense of clergy strength, has been a part of the backbone of American infrastructure, civic infrastructure, since going way back, and Alexis de Tocqueville noticed it when he came to visit America in 1835.
And so we’re trying to reconnect clergy to that role as being a guardian of civic health, in addition to whatever prophetic leadership and policy advocacy that clergy get involved with parallel to that is this role of civic guardianship.
BANKS: Thank you.
Maggie, what would you add about what you’re doing to try to diffuse, if that’s the right word, you know, some of the concerns that are happening?
SIDDIQI: I love that phrase that Michael just said of serving as a guardian of civic health. We’ve been thinking of a lot of the faith leaders we work with as sort of election protection ambassadors.
In addition to encouraging folks to sign up as poll chaplains with efforts such as Reverend Salguero’s, we’ve encouraged folks to serve as poll workers so, like, work—you know, volunteering or working for their local election process and, you know, helping administer everything.
And we’ve had faith leaders who have set up meetings with election officials just to understand the process and make sure that if there are questions about what happens on election day, they have a better sense of how to answer that because they will have seen firsthand, like, how do votes get counted and what does that actually look like.
We’re also encouraging them to serve as trusted messengers to their community, so if there are instances of misinformation or disinformation, they can help correct that either because they’ve seen what it looks like firsthand or because they know who to ask to check and verify information and make sure that rumors aren’t spread, and, you know, so that’s a really important role to play.
And then also, you know, as Michael alluded to, so much of being a faith leader is sort of helping cast a vision forward for people and so they’re doing a lot of nonpartisan get-out-the-vote efforts as well because the exercise of voting is an exercise of casting forward whatever vision you have for your local community, for your state, for America. And so it is that exercise of hope.
And yeah, I think it’s true, faith leaders have often served as a guardian of civic health in that way and making sure everyone is encouraged to exercise that hope and that vision for the future.
BANKS: Thank you.
I know that today’s panelists are generally representing nonpartisan approaches to the election, but I’m wondering if there are any aspects of some of the races that are a particular concern to any of you, perhaps, where the faith of the candidate is being highlighted.
Would any of you like to speak to that?
HOLZMAN: I mean, I would like to speak to what’s happening in Michigan because I think the attacks on, you know, Abdul El-Sayed for being Muslim are just ugly, ugly Islamophobia. I know the Jewish community in Michigan—I’m not from Michigan. I don’t want to speak as a member—a voter in Michigan, but I know the Jewish community in Michigan is deeply divided over, you know, policy statements and, like, genuine things that the voters get divided over. Like, that’s what elections are for.
But, you know, besmirching someone because of their faith background is just off limits, and that’s been happening, actually. It’s been happening to Christian pastors. I mean, it’s been happening to, you know, people who are in—James Talarico. His faith has been questioned, right?
I mean, in Kansas it’s happening, and choosing to pick on someone because of their faith has always been, in my opinion, out of bounds in American politics, and the Overton window of what’s considered to be acceptable behavior has moved, unfortunately.
I think some of the data that Greg is pointing to about how the way people are anxious about the election has become partisan. It’s not people have different, you know, partisan red anxieties and blue anxieties. I think that’s really, really scary to me because elections used to be the day when we stood in line next to our neighbors and no one cared what your party was. It was just your neighbor, right? And the person who took your ballot was the mom from the PTA and the person who put the ballot in the machine was a grandpa from the church down the street.
And, like, I trust those people implicitly because I see them all the time at the supermarket, and the idea that those people are going to be besmirched and denigrated, that—insulting the electoral process is actually insulting the PTA mom and the grandpa from down the street. That really offends me, and picking on faith in this electoral season really has been very disturbing.
SALGUERO: Yeah, thank you, Rabbi. I appreciate that. I think it’s true.
We, in this country, have people of many faiths, of no faith, and people who are searching faith, and people who are concerned about faith, and in a religiously pluralistic society we have to know how to navigate that with civility, even as we hold to conviction.
My concern is the scapegoating of immigrant people and the narrative that often borrows from the Huntington thesis—Samuel Huntington thesis—the clash of civilizations, that somehow Asians who come to America, or Latinos, or Asians, or Africans are invading hordes that are going to somehow so change our nation in a negative way, and it’s as if we’re moving away from the promise of democracy.
The rabbi quoted Tocqueville and others. It’s kind of e pluribus unum—out of many, one—and that’s the richness of the tapestry of the mosaic of this country.
So I’m really concerned when candidates from any stripe, left, right, or center, use immigrants as a scapegoat and as saying, well, if these immigrants come into our country, somehow it’s going to lessen the quality of life, less—we’re going to be somehow less American.
And so that rhetoric is deeply concerning, particularly when it lurches over into the realm of xenophobia and anti-Semitism or any other anti-faith group—anti-Islamic. I think that our democracy is strong enough that we can disagree civilly, we can have deep disagreements without being cruel or without being hateful or without engaging in stereotyping. And that’s why so many of us are engaging in poll chaplain work and deescalating work.
Because after the elections, we’re still going to be neighbors. Before the elections we’re neighbor, and after the elections we’re going to be neighbors, and we need to, in the words of Jesus, love our neighbors as we love ourselves.
SIDDIQI: Just I would build off of that.
And I think, you know, unfortunately, periods of hate—I’ll just speak as somebody who’s been in the Muslim community for a long time serving in our organizations. We know there is data that shows that hate against our community peaks during election cycles or other key political moments. You would think it would correspond to, you know, violent attacks or things like that.
No, the corresponding, the what—the spikes in anti-Muslim hate always correlate to election cycles, and it’s been absolutely devastating to see the hate rising against Muslim communities, against immigrants, against so many different groups during this election cycle in particularly egregious ways that I think folks need to know we’ll really outlive this election, right?
The election will end. There will be results, right? Whoever wins, wins. The impacts on our communities will stay. And so it’s been really important for us to call out this hate wherever we see it.
And yes, oftentimes it is leveled against candidates. We saw just this week Senator Bernie Moreno said Abdul El-Sayed had no right to be anywhere near Washington, D.C., because he doesn’t understand Jesus as his savior, imposing a clear religious litmus test on a candidate for office, which is a violation of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution from a sitting senator.
The DHS Secretary, I think just a week ago, went on TV and spoke about—made up all these things about Islam that, quite frankly, I, as somebody who went to seminary, had never learned about Islam, claiming that we’re obligated to lie and, you know, all of these things that were deeply, deeply harmful rumors to spread about our community and really devastating, you know, I think to the fabric of our country and to our understanding of religious freedom.
And as has been said, it’s not just something that’s being leveled against candidates all year this year. There have been hearings focused on Muslim communities or focused on other minority communities as some kind of threat amongst us that has been really deeply harmful at a very local level to a lot of folks.
BANKS: Thank you all for addressing that.
Greg, I wondered if you had any context about any of what we were just discussing as far as what the mood and the level of hatred that people may hear voiced at election time. Do you have any context to add to that?
SMITH: I don’t have a lot of specific data about how election time corresponds to ebbs and flows and what people think about other groups. We do know that there are people in the United States who have reservations about people from other religious backgrounds, and we know—we have asked over the years—not in this cycle, I don’t think, but we’ve asked over the years about different kinds of traits that presidential candidates, for example, might have and whether those traits are things that would make people more likely to vote for them or less likely to vote for them, and religious factors can come into play there.
We know, for example, that voters have tended to say over the years that they would be less likely to vote for an atheist candidate for president. That’s one group that actually often gets kind of singled out in American life in terms of people expressing dislike or distaste. So there’s a lot of that that goes on.
One thing I would share that comes out in the data and in light of some of the community connections that were just being described and how that can kind of serve to bridge some of these divides, that comes through in the data when you ask people what they think about other religions.
It turns out that in many cases, people who say they have friends from another religious group or who say they know a lot about another religious group, those folks tend to have more positive views of Muslims or Jews or Catholics or—than the people who say they don’t have friends among the people of that group.
So I think that does speak to the power and the importance of some of the community ties that we’ve been talking about today.
BANKS: Thank you.
I just want to ask maybe one or two more questions before we open up for the general audience to ask whatever they wish.
One of the topics that sometimes gets lost in the midst of the overall elections is ballot measures, which are farther down on the ballot, and so I’m wondering if there’s any that anyone would point to that might be consequential, depending on whether they’re voted up or down or are a source of concern within the areas that they’re located or amongst the people they represent.
HOLZMAN: Yeah, if I can, I want to just jump in on that because my synagogue is on a property that is immediately adjacent to a Catholic church. And I’m in Virginia and the Archdiocese, the bishop of Arlington, sent instructions to all the churches in the diocese to put up signs and to advocate against the ballot measures for protecting gay marriage, for protecting a woman’s right to choose, that are on the Virginia ballot this year.
And it’s not partisan to—for a religious group to teach their theology and the way in which their theology supports a certain point of view on these kinds of policy issues. It’s not at all partisan. I mean, you can’t read the Bible without coming up with some policy issues, right, so if you’re going to be honest.
However, I think there’s a way to do it and there’s a way not to do it, right. And so, you know, unfortunately, I’ve talked to my neighboring priest. There’s a gigantic sign, right, that they’ve put up and the language on the sign is very misleading and it’s very—in my opinion, it’s really—it’s not entirely honest about what the ballot measures say. And it’s a huge sign that’s usually used to advertise upcoming Catholic holidays and to celebrate the new Pope and to talk about Catholic things.
And I think when religious institutions put lawn signs on—in front of the building, it’s not great for democracy. I think our religious institutions are meant to be—meant to be someplace that says a symbol for all of us as a unifying symbol in the neighborhood.
Obviously, on the pulpit, when the pastor or the rabbi or the imam has to preach, they need to be true to their theology and they need to preach the message that, you know, these policies align with our theology. I think that’s totally fair game.
But when we’re speaking to the public outside of our buildings, I think we have a greater responsibility to represent a kind of civic whole and not encourage constant divisiveness that we’re surrounded by with our phones and media. We shouldn’t be living politics all the time, and I think our churches and synagogues and mosques should be separate spaces from that to some degree.
Like I said, our theologies need to speak honestly and we need to provide some peace for the community as well.
BANKS: Gabriel?
SALGUERO: Yeah, I think one major issue that may go unnoticed is funding for religious schools. It is not a small thing amongst Latino Evangelicals. More and more Latino Hispanic Evangelicals and others—but I’ll speak about the group I know most—have schools that are serving—they’re charter schools or religious charter schools that are serving historically underserved and underrepresented communities.
Historically, and I know the debate well about charter schools and segregation and how some groups left other groups behind—I know that well.
But there’s a new nuance when there’s Haitian Christian schools and African-American Christian schools and Latino schools, many of whom feel that their children are underserved or marginalized in public school system.
I was a public school teacher. I am pro public school, and so I want to be clear about that. I serve on the faith-based committee of our county of public schools, and I’m in Orlando, Florida, and Florida has a lot of money going to schools, and it’s having its impact on public schools.
That being said, it is going to be and it continues to be a voting priority, particularly for those school—for those churches who have schools. So wherever people fall on that debate, I think it’s being either they’re overlooked or ignored that that is a voting priority for some faith-based groups, and I think it’s an important talking and point and conversation.
Perhaps not for this circle, but I think it’s one that many pundits may have not seen, that this charter school thing is not just historic white Evangelicals and privileged schools, that there’s a growing number of faith-based minority-run schools that are part of this conversation.
BANKS: Thank you.
Lastly, I’d like to ask a little bit about partnerships. When I’ve done some reporting I’ve noticed that black Baptist churches are hosting some of the stops at the Interfaith Alliance bus tour that Maggie mentioned, and there are other groups working where it’s church leaders, but also civil rights leaders and labor leaders who are saying, we need to work together to emphasize getting the vote out, encouraging people.
And I’m wondering what you’re seeing about this, whether you think there are more partnerships or different partnerships for this midterm.
HOLZMAN: I’m looking at Maggie.
SIDDIQI: I mean, personally, I think, you know, there have been a lot more partnerships. I think some of the work that we’re really proud of is our partnerships with a lot of secular organizations like the League of Women Voters or Indivisible, Protect Democracy, and ensuring that the efforts—the nonpartisan efforts they’re engaged in are working part and parcel with faith communities and ensuring that we are sharing resources that are from these civic institutions with faith communities as well.
And so there’s that sort of, like, ongoing dialogue that I think that that bridging was long overdue and feels like it’s really happening this year, and through our bus tour, I think one of the things that’s been really exciting is the opportunity to not only work with such diverse local partners in every different stop.
There was one weekend that I participated in where in one day we were at a mosque, a gurdwara, and then two synagogues that night on that Friday, and then we were at a black church on Sunday. We were at Malcolm X’s former mosque on Saturday for a canvassing event. Like, it was a very religiously diverse weekend.
So not only all of those diverse local partnerships but also, you know, one of the leaders from the Sikh-American Legal Defense and Education Fund, SALDEF, joined us for part of the bus tour and just, you know, came with us from stop to stop.
So getting that—you know, the sort of diverse national partnership as well. The participating, I think, has been a way that—you know, I feel like those partnerships are getting deeper and broader in ways that I haven’t seen before in my career.
BANKS: Thank you for those examples.
HOLZMAN: I’d just love to give a very quick shoutout for the LDS Church.
I just want to just elevate the fact that when Faith 250 started we had no relationship with the LDS Church, and somewhere in January or February, all of our local clusters—we have forty-eight local clusters right now and at that time then it was about thirty clusters, and all of them started reporting that the LDS Church had shown up.
The local stake—you know, a stake represents maybe eight congregations, and when in interfaith work, very often interfaith work appeals to groups that are in the center and left politically. The LDS community generally votes to the right. So when we get people into conversation with the LDS church—the Latter-Day Saints—they bring a level of political diversity and viewpoint diversity into the room.
And I have to tell you, the experience for so many people was so—was really inspiring because of the way they handled themselves with respect and dignity and compassion for others, and the experience of political diversity was really just a source of great hope for everybody. This myth that we have to polarize everything and we have to separate and be afraid of people who disagree with us, it’s really depressing.
However, you know, when we get together and I love what Maggie’s saying about the bus because, like, you’re face to face with people, right? And when you have that face-to-face encounter, that’s when God’s presence appears. And so I think that’s a great deal of hope for people.
SALGUERO: I’d love to dovetail on what both Maggie and the rabbi have said, as an Evangelical.
It is probably one of the most challenging things for us, and if I’m going to be as transparent as I can be, many times when we’re engaged in interfaith democracy work, those of us who are Evangelical and who may be seen—although Evangelicals are not a monolith and Latino Evangelicals less so, I think—that if we hold some conservative views you can’t talk with us.
And reverse—in the reverse, we won’t talk with you. It’s exactly what Rabbi Holzman says. There’s fear, there’s suspicion that the cost of entering into this conversation is me obviating my deepest conviction, that somehow civil religion in America is really conservatives not speaking their mind. That historical suspicion is there, and we’ve had to do a lot of work on that and we are doing work on that.
That being said, we’ve worked deeply—NALEC, our coalition—with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on immigration. We’ve worked with the Catholics and the LDS on ethics and artificial intelligence, which is a deepening concern in our communities, particularly the protection of our children and their mental health.
And so we’ve worked with Jewish rabbis and imams on protecting children, on protecting houses of worship against anti-Semitic and anti-Islamic and anti-immigrant hate.
And my church, for example—I’m not just a leader of a coalition, I pastor a local church in central Florida—is a voting site. Many of our churches are voting sites because people feel comfortable coming into houses of worship.
So there’s a lot of cross-pollination. But if we’re really going to get over some of the historical suspicions, we have to speak frankly and transparently about how civil religion oftentimes has suspicion of Evangelicals and other groups.
BANKS: Thank you to all of you for this discussion so far.
It’s probably time now to turn to questions, and we look forward to hearing from our audience.
OPERATOR: Thank you all. Let’s open it up to questions.
(Gives queueing instructions.)
We will take a written question from Brian Corbin with Catholic Charities USA: Gabriel noted, if I heard him correctly, that Evangelical Hispanics will turn out more to vote than Hispanic Catholics. Can you explain further? Thanks.
SALGUERO: Thank you, Brian.
Actually, what I said is that Hispanic Evangelicals will turn out more to vote conservatively than their Hispanic Catholic counterparts. I don’t think we’ll have a larger turnout. There are actually way more Hispanic Catholics than there are Hispanic Evangelicals, by more than double. If we’re 22 percent of the Latino population, Hispanic Catholics are over 50 percent.
But historically—and I think Gregory has said there is some shifting because of immigration and because of the economy and because of racial profiling and other issues—historically, Latino Evangelicals vote at higher rates on the conservative side than the Hispanic Catholic counterparts.
That’s the data that I was trying to state. So thank you for that clarifying question, Brian.
BANKS: Greg, go ahead.
SMITH: I would just confirm that the patterns that Gabriel describes are, indeed, what we see in the data. You often see, whether it’s in terms of people’s party preferences or their views about issues, Latino Evangelicals tend to be a very interesting group because they are more conservative, on the one hand, than Latino Catholics, but they are less conservative than white Evangelicals. So they occupy kind of a middle ground in that sense.
I think the question is right to ask about and focus on turnout. I think turnout is a big factor in any election, including this one. It’s not just who do people vote for but who turns out to vote. That’s an important question.
And one just sort of demographic factor to keep in mind, I haven’t looked at these data recently but I suspect they’re still true. You have to keep in mind that there are differences among Latinos in terms of the share of people in different religious groups who are immigrants versus people who have been born in the United States to immigrant parents versus people whose families have been here for a longer period of time.
And those things in turn can be correlated with civic engagement and things like turning out to vote. So those are some things to bear in mind too when thinking about the important question of voter turnout.
OPERATOR: We will take the next written question from William Luther Martin: Texas Governor Abbott attacks Talarico for saying that God is non-binary. Is this quote really disqualifying for Evangelicals as in Proverbs, wisdom is female and exists from the beginning like God?
And as a reminder, you can all raise your hands and also submit a question via the Q&A box. We’d love to hear your questions.
BANKS: Who would like to take that on?
SMITH: Sam, can you just repeat that? The question, like, it was very technical. Can you repeat the question?
OPERATOR: Yes.
Texas Governor Abbott attacks Talarico for saying that God is non-binary. Is that quote disqualifying for Evangelicals? In Proverbs, wisdom is female and exists from the beginning like God.
SALGUERO: Well, I guess as an Evangelical, I should try to respond.
First of all, I want to begin by saying that Evangelicals are not a monolith. I need to underscore that. I don’t pretend to speak for all Evangelicals. I don’t pretend to speak for all Latino Evangelicals, over 10 million of us. So I want to say that.
If you’re asking on the PR side, absolutely. If you polled a bunch of Evangelicals, right, if we’re just doing demographic data, yes. Yes, because the language is not reflective of the Evangelical theology taught in the pew, taught in the congregation, and how many Evangelicals view scripture.
If you asked a bunch of theologians, Evangelical theologians from the Evangelical Theological Society or Society of Pentecostal Studies, then we’d get into this. As the rabbi said, it’s a very technical question.
Most theologians would say that God is sui generis, that God is the only one of God’s type. There’s none like God in all the earth, right?
And so the issue is that Mr. Talarico is trying to, I don’t know, make a political statement through theological nuance, and that just doesn’t work. So whoever’s advising him, yes, the answer is yes, it is disqualifying for most Evangelicals if you did a study.
If you’re having a theological discussion in a seminary, that’s a different question. But on the public relations side, many Evangelicals would disqualify him.
SMITH: If I could just add.
It’s an interesting question, and it’s interesting to think about what a study or what a poll might show if you were able to ask people directly that question is this comment disqualifying. We haven’t done that. I’d be interested to see what it shows.
One thing it reminds me of, though, and one thing we do have a lot of public opinion data about is what sorts of issues people say they prioritize when it comes time to vote. And, you know, when we think about religious voters, it can be tempting to think that religious voters care about a certain constellation of issues that’s unique to them and that other people might not share, and I think the issues that come to mind are things like abortion and also issues about sexuality, issues related to the LGBTQ community.
It actually turns out that when you ask people what sorts of issues are important to them when they decide how to vote, those things rank pretty low even for religious voters, even for Evangelicals.
People’s issue priorities, I think, are actually something that brings people together across a religious group rather than divides them. What do I mean?
Well, when we ask people what factors come into play when they think about how to vote, there’s a number-one issue across the board and it’s the economy, regardless of people’s religion. And there are other factors too that tend to score very high, concerns about the future of democracy. People in a wide variety of religious groups tell us that matters to their vote.
Gabriel mentioned education a few minutes ago. That’s another issue that is not at the top but near the top of many people’s voting priorities. Abortion ranks much lower, even among Evangelicals. They think it’s more important than some other groups, but it’s not as important for them as the economy or the future of democracy.
And in our recent survey, we asked people specifically about issues and policies related to LGBTQ Americans and fewer than one in five people say that that’s going to factor prominently in the way they vote this November, even among religious voters, even among Evangelicals. That’s pretty far down the list.
So whether that comment is disqualifying if you put it to somebody, you know, yes or no, white or black, you have to tell me right now is this comment disqualifying, I’m not sure. Where do LGBTQ issues, matters related to sexuality, rank in people’s voting priorities? They tend to be pretty far down the list.
SALGUERO: Yeah, let me give some nuance to this, because I think we need nuance to the question.
Do you mean politically disqualifying or theologically disqualifying, right? And so maybe as a pastor and a theologian that’s how I read it.
Gregory’s quite right. Religious voters, like other voters, are not one-issue voters. They have a panoply of issues that they vote for. So I read the question in the theological framework because it’s how it was framed, which is, yes, as an Evangelical, that would be theologically disqualifying for the most of them.
Politically, it’s right. People might put economy before this, or immigration or racial profiling or, I mean, the invasion of Venezuela, Latin American politics, what’s going on in Cuba. The list is long.
So I think Gregory’s quite right if he’s talking politically. If it’s theological, that’s a different conversation.
SMITH: Gabriel, I’m curious what you think of the idea of the governor of Texas giving theological, you know, instructions to people. I mean, that’s the part of the question I got hung up on was the governor of Texas was saying this is disqualifying for Evangelicals, and we’ve seen, like, Vice President Vance telling the Pope not to talk theology, right?
I mean, like, so, like, our politicians are trying to insert themselves into theological conversations here.
SALGUERO: I think it is historically consistent that politicians from the left, right, and center talk religion and try to denounce the religious perspective of their person running against them. I’ve seen that on every side, and so I’m not surprised.
So what do I think about it? It rains in April. That’s what I think about it. I think it’s historically consistent with politicians who are trying to garner the religious vote or a particular religious vote. They’re going to pick theological points that they think their base agrees with them and decry how the opponent sees it.
And so that’s what I think about it, and I’ve seen it and I will continue to see it. And I lament it when religion and faith is used as a linchpin to polarize us against each other. I have deep lament for that.
HOLZMAN: Yeah. What worries me about that is the difference—we haven’t really talked about it much today, but the difference between the church and the unchurched, and I know Greg has data on the nones who are people who say they have no religion. But there’s a lot of people who say they have religion and never go to church. Evangelicals, too, and believe me, Jews all the time.
And I think that if you’re going to learn your theology from the internet or learn your theology from a politician, you’re putting yourself at a spiritual disadvantage in your own—inside your own faith, and I think one of the things we’re experiencing as a country is that people aren’t experiencing faith through an encounter with the actual interior of their religion, inside their building, with their pastor, with their congregation, in the pew, and I think it’s a different experience when you learn theology that way than when you learn it from the internet or from a meme that’s being circulated by a politician.
Maggie, did you want to jump in?
SIDDIQI: Yeah, if I may on that point.
I mean, look, I find the question theologically very fascinating, right? God says in the Quran that he uses the pronoun he, but that he is neither male nor female, right? And so, like, I would love to have a whole theological conversation.
I don’t think that’s why it’s part of the discourse. The reason why it’s part of our political discourse right now is to scapegoat LGBTQ people alongside all of the other communities we named earlier in the context of an election cycle in a way that will have long-lasting consequences, in this case specifically for non-binary or trans folks for long after the election.
And so to fixate on that statement, to me, is just a way of sort of, again, drawing attention to, you know, a minority community here as like the problem, when, as Greg said, voters will tell you from left to right that is not their primary concern.
And so even the attempt to elevate that in the conversation is really doing harm and not, you know, directly addressing, I think, what folks want to be talking about no matter where they are on the political spectrum.
OPERATOR: Thank you. Our next written question is from John Cho with Tufts University: It seems like there’s been a surge or resurgence of progressive/liberal Christian politics on the national stage embodied in James Talarico, Reverend Adam Hamilton, and in earlier elections Raphael Warnock and Andy Beshear. Does this seem or feel new, perhaps, in reaction to the brand of Christianity in the White House?
BANKS: Who would like to answer that? Go ahead.
SMITH: I just want to point out it’s not just actual pastors or seminarians. It’s also politicians speaking about their faith in really organic and authentic terms.
I mean, Josh Shapiro began his gubernatorial campaign with a video about observing the Sabbath with his family so—and obviously, a politician of the left. So I think that in the Eighties and the Nineties the right really co-opted religion as theirs and I think there has been a concerted effort that’s been going on for a long time for politicians of the center and left to reclaim religious language that’s often very, very authentic because they’re practicing people of faith, but to find a way to do that in the political sphere with—you know, with a degree of comfort.
SALGUERO: Yeah. I’m old enough to remember when Senator Lieberman ran for national office and he talked about keeping the Sabbath and as part of his tradition and his deepest commitments.
I know Senator Warnock pretty well because we both went to seminary together. He lived two doors down from me and so I know when he was at Abyssinian and other places. And so I think it’s part of—historically, the African-American church has had many clergy who’ve run for office. And so I think that there’s more attention to it, given the swings of who is in office and what religious group gets attention.
But I remember that former President Obama had to give a speech on his religion when there was a lot of media attention to it. And so I do think there’s renewed attention to it but I do think that it’s part of the historical pattern with different degrees of accent, no pun intended.
BANKS: Maggie, you had something? Go ahead.
SIDDIQI: Yeah, you know, the nation did have a progressive Christian leader in the White House with Jimmy Carter some years back, so that aspect is not new that sort of folks who are very open or even leaders in the Christian faith have then, you know, also run for office as progressives.
I think what’s really interesting is we’ve seen a trend, perhaps in reaction to the—as Michael named, the sort of right-leaning leading with Christian faith that we’ve seen over the past few decades, there’s almost been a reaction on the left I’d say, largely, among white Christians specifically, to say, I want separation of church and state but to sort of take that too far and to say, as a result, I won’t even talk about what my faith values are. I won’t even express that to the public.
And we’re seeing a really interesting desire to thread that needle to say this is what I believe and this is why my faith leads me to do this work, and I believe that everyone else should have equal right to, you know, their own faith tradition.
And so I think that is the voice that is, perhaps, more uniquely among, I’d say, white Christians specifically, because as we’ve named, a lot of leaders of the black church have continued to run for office and be very open about their faith. I think religious minorities are frequently called upon to have to explain their faith and how that relates to their public office.
And so Joe Lieberman, Josh Shapiro, right, that part is not new either, but this sort of, I’d say, what feels new since Jimmy Carter almost is white progressive Christians kind of leading with their faith in this way.
OPERATOR: Our next written question is from Richard Rubenstein with George Mason University: To what extent will religious people’s votes be influenced by their disapproval of wars, like the war on Iran, and their commitment to peaceful negotiations?
HOLZMAN: I’ll jump into this one at big risk because I think that the war in Gaza has definitely affected American politics in a big way.
It’s not just the war in Gaza, but it’s the entire Benjamin Netanyahu strategy of polarizing Israel as a partisan issue, which he’s been doing his entire career, going back to when he spoke in front of Congress against the president’s wishes when President Obama was in office.
And so the combination of Netanyahu’s desire to polarize Israel as a Republican cause and the fact that the Gaza war was taking place in the social media era with so much intimacy and so much ability for people to be encountering and interacting with the horrors of what was happening during that war on both sides, actually—you know, hearing stories from the families of hostages, hearing stories from parents whose children have been killed by a bomb.
I mean, it’s so intimate and so immediate, right? We had intimacy in the Vietnam War, but it took a long time for the footage to get back to the country.
And so that has really injected into American discourse and American political discourse a level of disgust for war and an emotional reaction to war that we haven’t seen, I think, in our politics for a little while.
There has been a real—on the right there’s been a real anger at forever wars and the Iran war has kind of really backfired on—no pun intended—on the administration, because so many of their supporters have been opposed to forever wars in the Middle East and the Iran war is turning out to be one of those.
And—but I think it’s a different kind of opposition to war. It’s more strategic and economic, and there’s a long history of that in American politics.
BANKS: Greg, is there anything you’d want to add from your research?
SMITH: Well, yes.
Actually, the first thing I want to add is I was thrilled to hear the question come from George Mason University. I’m an alum of George Mason. My son is a student there now. So that was kind of thrilling, so thank you for the question.
I guess the main thing I would add is that there’s a couple of ways of looking at this. Well, there’s probably a lot of ways of looking at it. But from the standpoint of public opinion data, we have asked people directly how important foreign policy will be as an issue when it comes time to vote and it ranks kind of in middle of the pack—you know, not as high as some other issues but higher than many others.
But, of course, that’s when you ask about it directly. I’m not sure how you would go about trying to actually separate that from the possible indirect effects because, of course—I say of course even though I’m not an economist, but my understanding is that things like war have a big impact on things like gasoline prices, which in turn have a big impact on things like the economy, which, of course, people rank A number one.
So I think there’s sort of a way—I think we have to keep in mind that you can think of both about the direct effect of foreign policy or the war in Iran or other foreign policy conflicts, but also their ripple effects as they’re expressed through other things like the economy.
OPERATOR: We will take our next written question from Tim Stratford with the G20 Interfaith Forum and the International Center for Law and Religion Studies: Aside from theological questions, to what extent do adherents to our various faith traditions attach importance to the personal morality and integrity of candidates?
BANKS: Which one of you would like to take that up? It seems like it could fit almost any of you.
SALGUERO: I’d love to hear, Gregory, I’m just fascinated before I weigh in to see if there’s any research on that, because that is a kitchen table conversation in our family and in our tribe of Evangelicalism. So I’d love to hear if there’s anything on that first.
SMITH: For sure. I’ll be very quick.
There is a lot of research on this. This was once sort of the purview of Republicans and think of family value conservatives, and in some ways it still is.
But we’ve asked some really interesting questions about religion and Donald Trump in particular. We’ve asked people, how religious do you think Donald Trump is? And most people do not think he’s particularly religious. Even his strongest supporters do not think that he’s particularly religious himself.
They do not necessarily think that he shares their own religious convictions. They don’t always have the highest regard for his own morality and honesty. So that’s the first thing to know.
So what is it then that they look to him for religiously? What they’re looking to him for is to stand up for people like them and there they say he does a much better job. They say, I don’t necessarily think he’s particularly religious himself. I don’t necessarily think that we share the same religious beliefs or convictions. But I think he stands up for people with religion like mine, and that’s, I think, kind of the key or one of the—one of the keys to understanding the relationship between Donald Trump and some of his more religious supporters.
SALGUERO: Thank you, Gregory.
That is my experience, that historically Evangelicals used to—they led with that. Morality and character matters.
You know, I remember when the scandals in the Nineties, many Christian radio—Evangelical radio stations, how can you have someone in the White House who lacks moral fortitude and—I was a child, but I remember it well. I remember it being preached in the churches that I was a member as a young boy and as a teenage young man.
And so I think that religious groups, like any other groups, our humanity lurks and our hunger for political power and political expediency will sacrifice moral character. If the person from the other party you see them as immoral, no problem, saying how immoral—we can’t have him or her in the office.
But if someone from your party you see them acting immorally or inhumanely to other people, well, at least he or she stands up for—so their morality counts because they protect our moral worldview. So it’s less about personal morality and it’s about this understanding of Weltanschauung, of worldview.
And so I see that all the time. In this last past election and elections prior, there were candidates from both sides who really—you know, I am hesitant to talk about the Epstein files and how many people from all political stripes are implicated in that. And sometimes—and here’s where independent religious and moral voices have to say, we’re here to call balls and strikes, not to get political power.
And the sad truth is that I have seen religious leaders sacrifice personal morality and moral integrity at the altar of political expediency because we must win. But sometimes a temporary win sacrifices the credibility of our faith witness, and the truth is because stakes are so high in our own imagination about political results we critique the immorality of people with whom we disagree and we somehow do moral gymnastics for the immorality of people who represent our political preference.
OPERATOR: We will take the final written question from Ari Gordon with the American Jewish Committee: Several panelists talked about the ways fear and hate against a candidate’s faith group are invoked to score political points. The stoking of Islamophobia and anti-Semitism to win votes is particularly bad these days. It also seems like some dismiss the accusations of Islamophobia or anti-Semitism as silencing political adversaries. This environment makes it hard for reasoned policy disagreement. How do we help communities discern between hate and debate?
HOLZMAN: That’s a great question, and it’s so wonderful to hear your voice, Ari, and, you know, your wisdom is really valuable here.
I think it kind of dovetails nicely with what Gabriel was talking about because I do think that hate and a desire to punish one’s enemies has become a moral virtue for some people, and I think that people sometimes can be—are becoming more and more addicted to the dopamine hit of hating their enemy and seeing their enemy get dumped on, you know, than actually caring about the content of the policy or the conversation.
And that is especially true in religious communities right now. We are in a phase where it feels like a spirituality of hatred and intolerance is becoming more and more common. I feel very strongly that it’s a gigantic mistake when pastors, rabbis, imams—when faith leaders endorse candidates, which, you know, this administration has said is now a fair game and they’re not going to be enforcing those elements of the tax code that forbid faith leaders from being partisan on the pulpit.
You know, and there are many in the Jewish community who have taken that opportunity to jump in and endorse candidates or preach against certain candidates, most notably in the Mamdani campaign for mayor of New York, as you know, Ari.
And I think it’s a humongous mistake, and it opens up faith leaders to getting so deeply involved in advocating for their preferred policy or candidate that they abandon exactly what Gabriel said. They abandon the legitimacy of their faith and they lose their credibility to stand on the platform of moral leadership because now they’re beholden to someone they’ve endorsed.
And so that’s the direction it feels like our country’s going in and I’m working—doing everything I can to work in the other direction.
SALGUERO: Ari, thank you for your question.
I have a great friend at AJC, Rabbi Noam Marans. I think one of the things we can do and should do, ought to do, is develop empathetic listening.
Your tradition is instructive in this. Shema Yisrael, hear, O Israel. I think that we are in the season of, you know, quick statements and talking heads and trying to get clickbait.
But the capacity to hear empathetically—the Middle East is one example of it, right? And so you feel, you hear, the trauma. And I met with AJC and I was on a panel after the events in October. You have to hear first. Before you try to respond, there has to be a good listening, and I don’t think that we’ve developed that civic muscle.
That doesn’t mean you speak—you don’t speak or you silence. I think there needs to be more listening and we have to develop that civic and spiritual and moral muscle. And then you speak from conviction without abandoning civility. So that’s the second muscle that I think we need to develop spiritually and morally.
I can deeply disagree with my fellow panelists here, but I should respect them and hear them and generally hear to understand, not just hear to rebut. And I think that our democracy is impoverished because many times religious leaders have taken on the ethos of the larger culture, which is let’s win at any cost.
You know, it’s the Johnson amendment, which the rabbi just talked about. Now—I would never endorse a candidate, never. The congregation I serve is very diverse and if we’re all thinking the same, we’re not all thinking.
But I do think that I should speak from a moral platform on policies that affect vulnerable people and communities and affect our common life together, and I think that if we’re able as faith leaders to have a moral—as Dr. King would say, we are not the master nor the servant of the state, we’re the conscience of the state, to hear empathetically and to speak pastorally and prophetic, our democracy will be richer.
SIDDIQI: I feel a legal obligation just to insert one thing, which is that just because this current administration says they will not enforce the Johnson amendment doesn’t mean it’s not still the law of the land. So not only is it inadvisable to endorse a candidate, it is also still illegal to do so, and I would caution against anyone doing that for any candidate on any political party.
Sorry, I just wanted to add that in there.
HOLZMAN: Thank you, counselor.
You know, and just as Gabriel quoted my tradition, I want to quote his. You know, Pastor Bob Roberts taught me something really, really important.
He said—he’s an Evangelical white pastor in Texas, and Pastor Roberts said, if I’m a man of conviction and I have any kind of integrity, then I need to know that I’m going to offend somebody because my convictions are going to disagree with theirs.
Therefore, I am obligated morally to carry myself with a posture that asks for repentance, that asks for forgiveness, right? That my convictions will offend and, therefore, I need to seek your forgiveness for the offense I’m going to cause to you by being a man of integrity, right?
That’s complicated stuff to do in American politics, and our media environment and our technology and our mindset, all of those things make it even tougher. But to be a human being that can carry one’s self with conviction, integrity, and a posture that asks for forgiveness and is willing to do repentance, like, that is the majesty of being a human being, right?
And so our faith traditions are here to help us do that and learn how to walk that line, and experience in our congregations, experience of prayer, experience of scripture study, these things help us learn how to be those kinds of people.
BANKS: I want to thank you all for this. Thank you to the panelists for what you have brought to this conversation, going in ways we probably didn’t expect but that were probably very helpful for our audience.
And Irina, thank you for inviting us to participate and to speak, and I turn it back over to you.
FASKIANOS: Yes. Thank you all for this conversation. We appreciate it, and to all of you for your questions. We will circulate the video and transcript so you can share it out, and please send us your suggestions for future topics and speakers to [email protected].
Again, thank you to all of you for the work that you’re doing. We really appreciate it, and we hope that you all have a wonderful rest of your day.
(END)




