from Pressure Points and Middle East Program

Israel to Head UN Committee for the First Time: So Much for Isolation

June 28, 2016

Blog Post
Blog posts represent the views of CFR fellows and staff and not those of CFR, which takes no institutional positions.

The argument that Israel is becoming increasingly isolated in the world took another blow this month when--for the first time in the history of the United Nations and of Israel--the Israeli ambassador was elected to head one of the UN’s permanent committees.  This the Legal Committee, also called the "Sixth Committee," and its covers the United Nations’ international law operations--which include matters related to terrorism and to the Geneva Conventions.

There was a tough diplomatic fight over this, so it is worth handing out kudos.

More on:

Israel

United Nations

Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

United States

Diplomacy and International Institutions

First, Israel’s ambassador Danny Danon, who was mocked by many on the Israeli Left and in the Israeli media (and yes, there is a large overlap) when Prime Minister Netanyahu appointed him, showed that he is a very competent diplomat. He was a member of the Knesset and a minister when appointed, but had had no diplomatic experience. He has obviously learned the job, and fast.

Second, kudos to the United States Mission to the UN, which fought very hard to get votes for Israel.

Third, kudos to those members of the "Non-Aligned Movement" who refused to go along with Palestinian, Arab League, and Iranian pressure to stop the Israelis. Three countries in particular stopped the anti-Israel effort: Singapore, Rwanda, and India. That last is noteworthy, because India’s new friendship for Israel is a great departure from its decades of hostility and because India has considerable weight at UN headquarters in New York.  It has been stated in the Arab press, though impossible to prove because there was a secret ballot, that several Arab countries actually voted for Israel. This entire episode is a humiliation for the Palestinian delegation in New York.

In the end Israel received 109 votes of 153 cast--a landslide. This victory for Israel shows how foolish is the line about Israel becoming increasingly isolated in the world. Relations with Turkey are about to be restored. Relations with several key Arab states are improving steadily. India’s new support is extremely significant. Israel maintains growing economic relations as well with China. It is true that many EU nations are increasingly critical of the Jewish state, which is significant because the EU is Israel’s largest trading partner (at least for now, while Britain remains in it). But at least in this case, the "Western European and Other Group" at the UN (which includes the United States, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand as well as the EU nations) did the right thing. Let’s suspend the mourning about Israel’s growing isolation for a moment of applause for this victory in Turtle Bay.

 

More on:

Israel

United Nations

Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

United States

Diplomacy and International Institutions

Up
Close