from Follow the Money

Another sign the world is changing

August 14, 2007

Blog Post
Blog posts represent the views of CFR fellows and staff and not those of CFR, which takes no institutional positions.

More on:


There was a time not-so-long ago when troubled banks in emerging economies, sometimes formerly state-run banks, looked to private banks in the US and Europe for equity infusions.  Now, well, troubled banks and broker-dealers in the US and Europe seem to be looking to banks -- often state-owned banks and investment companies -- in the emerging world for help ...

I (obviously) have no idea if CITIC is going to invest in Bear.  The Bear-China Construction deal never happened.  But it would be consistent with recent trends.

There was a strong presumption several years ago that China's financial system would -- over time -- evolve so that it looked more like the US financial system and, I suspect, an presumption that private US and European financial firms would be major players in China's domestic markets.  Now in a world of "reverse globalization" it is at least plausible that China's state (along with financial institutions controlled by China's state) could end up with a significant ownership stake in US banks, US broker-dealers and US private equity firms, which would, in a way, make the US financial system look a bit more like China's financial system. 

Potential ironies abound.  The US government has long resisted any suggestion that hedge funds be required to disclose their positions.   But CITIC buys a stake in Bear,  China's state -- through CITIC -- could conceivably end up having access to a fair amount of information about the positions of some US hedge funds.  Bear is a big prime broker, and a large equity investor like CITIC would certainly have every right to know what risks Bear is taking. 

It wouldn't be entirely unprecedented for a government to invest in a financial firm to get access to financial information:  the Bank of Italy claimed it invested in LTCM in part to understand how hedge funds were influencing the Italian BTP market ... 

The intermingling of public and private money -- in a world where "socialism is for capitalists" and "capitalism is for socialists" -- does raise some interesting questions -- questions that I am still struggling with. 

I wonder what Michael Pettis -- who worked for Bear at one time -- thinks ...

NOTE: I edited this post somewhat after initially posting it to try to make my intended meaning clearer, and also to correct a couple of egregious spelling errors.

More on: