from International Institutions and Global Governance Program

Bolstering the UN Human Rights Council’s Effectiveness

January 03, 2017

Report

More on:

Human Rights

Global Governance

Overview

Two successive terms of U.S. membership on the UN Human Rights Council (UNHRC), before the mandatory one-year hiatus, have improved the body’s performance in several ways. These improvements include strengthening the council’s commitment to country-level action, fortifying norms that underpin fundamental freedoms and assist at-risk populations, rebalancing the human rights agenda, and building momentum for the defense of civil society. U.S. membership has not, however, remedied all of UNHRC’s chronic ills. The UN General Assembly routinely elects to the council egregious rights violators such as China, Saudi Arabia, and, until recently, Russia. The UNHRC’s official agenda retains a standing agenda component, Item 7, focused exclusively on Israel. Human rights groups bemoan the UNHRC’s inadequate response to a rising tide of reprisals against human rights defenders. 

Mark P. Lagon

Chief Policy Officer, Friends of the Global Fight Against AIDS, Tuberculosis, and Malaria

Ryan Kaminski

Senior Program Manager for Human Rights, United Nations Foundation

U.S. participation in the UNHRC can advance U.S. interests and lessen anti-Israel bias while supporting measures to avert and de-escalate human rights crises, thus reducing the likelihood of costly military interventions. In this discussion paper, Mark P. Lagon and Ryan Kaminski explain how the United States can exercise catalytic leadership to create a stronger UNHRC.

Selected Figures From This Report

Country-Specific Special Procedure Mandates
Proportion of Country-Specific UNHRC Resolutions on Israel
Global Decline in Indicators of Nonviolent Civil Society Actors in the Past Decade
Freedom House Ratings of Countries' Support for Democracy and Human Rights in 2014

More on:

Human Rights

Global Governance

Top Stories on CFR

Ukraine

Ukraine has rejected recent calls by the West for it to settle its war with Russia. Ukrainian leaders believe they have a chance to reclaim territory lost in the early fighting—and that they can do so before serious negotiations begin.

Taiwan

In moving away from strategic ambiguity, Biden made a long overdue adjustment to U.S. policy.

South Korea

Presidents Biden and Yoon pledged to deepen and broaden the scope of the U.S.-South Korea alliance, but their success could depend on how China, Japan, and North Korea respond.