Radical Change in Refugee Policy is Required to Prevent Future Humanitarian Disasters and Massive Loss of Life

Radical Change in Refugee Policy is Required to Prevent Future Humanitarian Disasters and Massive Loss of Life

May 9, 2002 2:24 pm (EST)

News Releases

NEW YORK, May 9, 2002 -- Refugee policy has not kept pace with new realities in international and humanitarian affairs and should be radically changed to better address the needs of the uprooted, argues Arthur C. Helton, Director of Peace and Conflict Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations, in his new book The Price of Indifference: Refugees and Humanitarian Action in the New Century. His study demonstrates that recent policy failures have resulted in instability, terrible hardships, and massive loss of life. The current crisis in Afghanistan is a case in point.

The book, published by Oxford University Press in cooperation with the Council on Foreign Relations, systematically analyzes refugee policy responses over the past decade and calls for specific reforms to make policy more proactive and comprehensive. “Refugee policy must be more than the administration of misery,” says Helton. “Responses should be calculated to help prevent or mitigate future humanitarian crises.”

More on:

Refugees and Displaced Persons

Helton has examined all relevant cases in great depth, systematically discussing them with honesty and clarity, including the crises in Bosnia, Cambodia, East Timor, Haiti, Kosovo, Rwanda, and Somalia.

Helton persuasively argues that there are critical gaps in the capacity of the current international system to undertake effective humanitarian action. The author does not merely expose the deficiencies of current policies and institutions, but also recommends specific reforms.

Among the recommendations:




  • Refugee policy should anticipate crises better – and seek to mitigate them.



  • Advance planning is needed to make refugee policy tools more effective.



  • Humanitarian structures within governments, notably the United States, as well as the wide variety of international institutions involved in humanitarian action must be reoriented to cope with new challenges.



  • A new international entity for strategic humanitarian action and research (SHARE) should be established, outside of the U.N. system, to help make refugee policy and humanitarian action smarter.



  • The Price of Indifference gives fresh answers to old questions,” says Council President Leslie H. Gelb, “and although it may infuriate some international bureaucrats, this thought-provoking account will serve well our efforts to design workable solutions to humanitarian disasters. This is a very important book for both decision makers and academics interested in efforts to reform international refugee policy and U.S. responses to humanitarian crises.”




Arthur C. Helton, a leading expert on international refugee law and policy, founded and directed the Forced Migration Projects at the Open Society Institute in New York prior to joining the Council on Foreign Relations. Previously, he directed the Refugee Project at the Lawyers Committee for Human Rights.

More on:

Refugees and Displaced Persons

Advance praise for The Price of Indifference:

“This new and highly original book examines one of the most pressing issues facing the international community today - the issue of refugees. The author provides a very clear review of humanitarian action over the past decade, focusing his analysis on forced displacement and on the role of the United Nations. Mr. Helton not only asks important questions, but also makes ambitious policy recommendations. His book is a welcome contribution to the debate on humanitarian action, and will undoubtedly help us to manage humanitarian challenges better in the future.”

Kofi Annan, United Nations Secretary-General

“Masterfully written and innovative, Arthur Helton’s book offers a most comprehensive and insightful treatment of refugee issues. This work is a splendid combination of the author’s solid academic judgment and his practical familiarity with the subject.”

Sadako Ogata, Ford Foundation; Former United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees

“This is an important book which shows how critical the refugee issue is in the conduct of foreign policy. The refugee problem is often ignored by decision makers. But, as this book shows, most recent international crises have featured refugees. Policy makers should heed Arthur Helton’s recommendations and address refugee issues, if they are serious about peacemaking.”

Richard C. Holbrooke, Vice Chairman, Perseus, LLC; Former U.S. Representative to the United Nations


Top Stories on CFR


The Kurds are one of the world’s largest peoples without a state, making up sizable minorities in Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Turkey. Their century-old fight for rights, autonomy, and even an independent Kurdistan has been marked by marginalization and persecution.

Pharmaceuticals and Vaccines

The swift development of effective vaccines against COVID-19 was an unprecedented scientific achievement. But production challenges, vaccine nationalism, and new variants have all presented hurdles.

United States

Spurred on by worsening economic and political crises across Latin America, migration to the United States reached record levels in 2022. Here’s a look at the year’s major immigration stories.