In New Book, Authors Simon and Allin Advocate Containing Iran to Forestall Israeli Attack

In New Book, Authors Simon and Allin Advocate Containing Iran to Forestall Israeli Attack

November 22, 2010 10:17 am (EST)

News Releases

As the international community’s concern over Iran’s nuclear program grows, and UN Security Council sanctions against Iran prove to be ineffective, an apprehensive Israel gets closer to launching an attack on Iran, warn Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) Adjunct Senior Fellow Steven Simon and International Institute for Strategic Studies Senior Fellow Dana H. Allin.

More From Our Experts

In their new book, The Sixth Crisis: Iran, Israel, America and the Rumors of War, Simon and Allin write, “there is every reason to worry that, in the coming years or months, a fearful Israel will conclude that it is cornered, with no choice but to launch a preventive war aimed at crippling Tehran’s nuclear infrastructure and thereby removing—or at least forestalling—what Israelis consider a threat to the Jewish state’s very existence.”

More on:



Wars and Conflict

The authors predict that “the likelihood of Israel deciding to attack depends on Israeli assessments of U.S. and international resolve to block Iran’s pursuit of nuclear weapons capability; the state of the Iranian program; the amount of time a successful strike would buy to be worth the expected risks and costs; whether Israel believes there is a clandestine program, which would lead some Israelis to conclude that an attack would buy no time at all; and the effect of a strike on U.S.-Israel relations.”

Simon and Allin call this the “sixth crisis” that will reshape the Middle East and America’s role in it. The book details the previous five, which are:

-The 1956 plot by Britain, France, and Israel to retake the Suez Canal from Egypt.

More From Our Experts

-The extended crisis of 1967–1973—seven years that were bracketed by two Arab-Israeli wars.

-The 1979 Iranian revolution.

More on:



Wars and Conflict

-The 1990 invasion of Kuwait by Iraqi forces under Saddam Hussein.

-The September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States.

Simon and Allin warn that the “sixth crisis” would have a catastrophic impact on local stability and U.S. relations with regional actors. Should an attack happen, “air strikes against Iran’s nuclear facilities might not be a limited affair: in the worst case, they could ignite a general war between Israel and Iran that would suck in the United States; drive millions of Arabs, Sunnis, as well as Shi’a, to side with Iran; reinvigorate the terrorist jihad; destroy the Israel-Palestine peace process; and decisively end America’s attempt to restore its moral footing and reestablish its leadership role in the world.”

To prevent these outcomes, the authors call on the Obama administration to “construct a credible regime of containment, including sufficient reassurance in the form of strengthened military protection and guarantees for Israel and Arab states.” The goal of containment would be “to enforce a redline before weaponization, nuclear testing, or withdrawal from the NPT [nuclear nonproliferation treaty].”

While the authors encourage the further exploration of sanctions and mechanisms of diplomacy, “a successful regime of containment will also have to include a readiness, under certain circumstances, for U.S. military action. Washington can make clear that Iran’s use of nuclear weapons would trigger an overwhelming American retaliation through whatever means were necessary to guarantee the destruction and demise of Iran’s ruling regime.”

The authors conclude that “the compressed coil of disaster linking Iran, Israel, and the United States is not the only problem facing the Obama administration, and it may not even be its worst problem. But Iran’s defiance and Israel’s panic are the fuses for a war that could destroy all of Obama’s other ambitions. The sixth crisis could shape our world for many years to come.”

Praise for The Sixth Crisis:

“Sober, sobering, trenchant and important.”

Steve Coll, two time Pulitzer Prize Winner

“The best one-volume analysis of the Iran nuclear crisis in print.”

Peter Beinart, author of The Icarus Syndrome

“Mandatory reading. These two deeply knowledgeable and objective authors transcend the polarized public debate, explaining why a war with Iran is a very real possibility, but also an avoidable one.”

Samuel Berger, United States National Security Advisor, 1997-2001

“A masterful account of the defining security challenge of the decade. Dana Allin and Steven Simon are without illusions. Their book disposes of the myths on all sides to reveal the tough dilemmas faced by Washington and Jerusalem.”

Richard A. Clarke, author of Against All Enemies

To order, visit:

Steven Simon is adjunct senior fellow for Middle Eastern studies at the Council on Foreign Relations and a consultant on Middle East security.  He has taught at Princeton and Georgetown universities, after a U.S. State Department career that included service on President Clinton’s National Security staff.  He is the co-author of the prize-winning book, The Age of Sacred Terror, as well as The Next Attack.

Dana H. Allin is Senior Fellow for U.S. Foreign Policy and Transatlantic Affairs at the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) in London and the editor of Survival, a leading security studies journal.  He is also adjunct professor of European Studies at the SAIS Bologna center of Johns Hopkins University, and author of Cold War Illusions: America, Europe and Soviet Power, 1969-1989.

The Council on Foreign Relations is an independent, nonpartisan membership organization, think tank, and publisher dedicated to being a resource for its members, government officials, business executives, journalists, educators and students, civic and religious leaders, and other interested citizens in order to help them better understand the world and the foreign policy choices facing the United States and other countries. Since 1922, CFR has also published Foreign Affairs, the leading journal on international affairs and U.S. foreign policy. CFR takes no institutional positions on matters of policy.



Top Stories on CFR


Nigeria needs a change of direction, not a change of government.  

The War in Ukraine


The United States and its allies have imposed broad economic penalties on Russia over its war in Ukraine. As the conflict continues, experts debate whether the sanctions are working.