Could Climate Change Break Home Insurance?

For decades, U.S. homeowners have counted on property insurance to protect them from catastrophic loss if their homes are destroyed—and the U.S. economy has rested on the functionality of that model. But as this summer’s extreme weather broke records, private companies reduced their coverage. As climate disasters become more frequent, can home insurance hold up?

Play Button Pause Button
0:00 0:00
x
Host
  • Gabrielle Sierra
    Director, Podcasting
Credits

Asher Ross - Supervising Producer

Markus Zakaria - Audio Producer and Sound Designer

Molly McAnany - Associate Podcast Producer

Episode Guests
  • Nancy Watkins
    Principal and Consulting Actuary, Milliman
  • David Marlett
    Managing Director of the Brantley Risk & Insurance Center, Appalachian State University

Show Notes

Homeownership has long been a pillar of the U.S. economy. For many Americans, a house is by far their largest asset. Naturally, they want to protect it in case of disaster, so they buy home insurance. Today, that model is under threat. Why? Climate change.

 

Seeing the increasing destruction wrought by a changing climate, private insurers have opted to reduce or eliminate coverage in some states. Now facing the risk of losing home insurance in addition to the ever-present threat of natural disasters, Americans living in risky areas might be forced to confront a decision to leave their homes for good. The government has, thus far, stepped in to replace fleeing insurers, though its public insurance programs are more expensive for both homeowners and taxpayers. However, there are a number of other solutions policymakers can consider to reduce the risk of a climate change-fueled collapse of U.S. home insurance.

 

 

From CFR

 

Alice Hill, “Climate Change and U.S. Property Insurance: A Stormy Mix

 

Alice Hill, “The Age of Climate Disaster Is Here,” Foreign Affairs


 

From Our Guests

 

Nancy Watkins, “Prepared Testimony of Nancy Watkins,” [PDF] Risky Business: How Climate Change is Changing Insurance Markets, U.S. Senate Committee on the Budget

 

 

Read More

 

Michael Copley, Rebecca Hersher, and Nathan Rott, How Climate Change Could Cause a Home Insurance Meltdown,” NPR

 

Jean Eaglesham, “Home Insurers Are Charging More and Insuring Less,” Wall Street Journal

 

David D. Evans, Cody Webb, Eric J. Xu, “Wildfire Catastrophe Model Could Spark the Changes California Needs,” [PDF] Milliman 


 

Watch and Listen

 

Innovating Solutions to the Climate Crisis,” CFR.org


How Climate Change Is Impacting Home Insurance Premiums,” NBC News

Trade

Tariffs are often discussed in big, abstract terms—trade wars, economic strategy, global power struggles. But for ginseng farmers in Wisconsin, their effects are painfully personal. In this episode, Why It Matters dives into how tariffs work and how they’re hitting one of America's most niche yet lucrative exports: Wisconsin-grown ginseng.

Trade

Is a trade consensus in Washington even possible? Well, it used to be. In 1989, the Washington Consensus introduced ten economic principles that championed global trade and guided U.S. policy. This vision was embraced for decades, with trade seen as a bridge connecting nations and strengthening economies. However, by 2025, protectionism and trade wars are now threatening to unravel years of cooperation. So how did trade evolve from a symbol of unity to a flash point for global conflict?

Trade

There was once a broad consensus in Washington that trade was a force for good—a way to connect, grow, and prosper. But today, trade has evolved into something much bigger than just the exchange of goods. It’s become a powerful tool to rewrite the rules of foreign policy, reshape how the United States is viewed by the rest of the world, and steer us toward an increasingly uncertain future. When did this change begin, and where did we go off course?  

Top Stories on CFR

Cambodia

The legacy of atrocity crimes that took the lives of millions of Cambodians during the communist Khmer Rouge regime, and the need for credible justice for the survivors, led to the creation of a criminal tribunal while mass atrocities continued elsewhere in the world.

Trade

Tariffs are often discussed in big, abstract terms—trade wars, economic strategy, global power struggles. But for ginseng farmers in Wisconsin, their effects are painfully personal. In this episode, Why It Matters dives into how tariffs work and how they’re hitting one of America's most niche yet lucrative exports: Wisconsin-grown ginseng.

Sudan

As Sudan plunges into another chapter of fighting, the country is enduring the world’s worst humanitarian crisis at a time of drastically shrinking foreign aid.